Wed Dec 6 23:12:26 2017 Wed Dec 6 23:12:26 2017 Wed Dec 6 23:12:26 2017 Msieve v. 1.53 (SVN 993) Wed Dec 6 23:12:26 2017 random seeds: a35f440d ffd72a16 Wed Dec 6 23:12:26 2017 factoring 18990123508557902868419834986612849212629329047848408031918356871905091180915018818857084783656883790655928770567349115604303665109625610225945717466120031386943078873289069222693826896799892056101 (197 digits) Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 commencing number field sieve (197-digit input) Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 R0: 119738888098469732352733201 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 R1: -6705343098319824504035000000000000000000000000 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A0: 710432 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A1: 0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A2: 0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A3: 0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A4: 0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A5: 0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 A6: 35 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 skew 5.22, size 2.773e-14, alpha -0.778, combined = 8.262e-15 rroots = 0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 commencing relation filtering Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 setting target matrix density to 200.0 Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 estimated available RAM is 32087.4 MB Wed Dec 6 23:12:27 2017 commencing duplicate removal, pass 1 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175032 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175033 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -1 reading relation 148175036 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175037 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175038 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175039 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175040 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175043 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175044 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175045 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175047 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175048 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175049 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175051 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175052 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175057 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175059 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175060 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175061 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175064 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175066 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175067 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175068 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175069 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175070 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175072 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175074 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175075 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175076 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -1 reading relation 148175078 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175081 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175083 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175084 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175085 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175086 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175087 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175089 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175090 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175092 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175093 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175094 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175095 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175097 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175099 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175108 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175113 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175118 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175120 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175121 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175124 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175130 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175132 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175142 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175147 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175148 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175158 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175165 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175168 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175170 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175173 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175174 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175176 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175177 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175182 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175183 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175185 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175188 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175195 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175200 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175201 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175203 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175204 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175207 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175209 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175211 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175213 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175215 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175216 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175217 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175218 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175220 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175221 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175225 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175229 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175232 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175233 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175238 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175240 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175244 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175245 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175247 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175249 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175250 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175254 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175255 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175256 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175258 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175260 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175266 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175270 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175272 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175273 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175276 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175277 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175279 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175280 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175281 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175284 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175287 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175289 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175291 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175293 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175295 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175296 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175297 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175299 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175302 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175303 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175306 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175307 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175308 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175310 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175311 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175314 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175315 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175316 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175317 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175320 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175321 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175323 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175324 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175325 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175326 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175327 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175333 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175338 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175339 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175340 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175341 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175343 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175344 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175345 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175346 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175347 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175348 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175350 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175351 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175352 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175355 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175357 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175362 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175364 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175367 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175369 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175371 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175372 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175373 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175374 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175375 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175378 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175380 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175384 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175390 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175395 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175397 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175398 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175401 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175403 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175409 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175410 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175412 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175414 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175417 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175418 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175419 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175421 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175422 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175424 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175427 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175428 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175429 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175430 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175431 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175433 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175434 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175438 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175439 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175441 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175445 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175450 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -1 reading relation 148175455 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175461 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175465 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175469 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175473 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175475 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175476 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175478 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175480 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175489 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175490 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175491 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175492 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175500 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175503 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175504 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175505 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175506 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175508 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175513 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175514 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175516 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175517 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175518 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175519 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175521 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175522 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175524 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175525 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175526 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175529 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175530 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175531 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175532 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175533 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175536 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175537 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175538 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175539 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175540 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175541 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175542 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175543 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175544 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175545 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175546 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175547 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175549 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175550 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175551 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175554 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175555 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175556 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175557 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175558 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175559 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175562 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175563 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175564 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175565 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175566 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175569 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175570 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175571 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175575 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175576 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175580 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175581 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175582 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175592 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175594 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175595 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175596 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175597 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175598 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175599 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175600 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175601 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175603 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175604 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175606 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175607 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175608 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175610 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175611 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175614 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175616 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175617 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175619 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175621 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175622 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175623 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175625 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175626 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175629 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175630 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175631 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175632 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175633 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175634 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175637 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175639 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175640 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175645 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175646 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175649 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175651 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175653 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175656 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175658 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175660 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175661 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175662 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175665 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175667 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175669 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175670 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175671 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175678 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175681 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175682 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175683 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175684 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175685 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175686 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175690 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175692 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175693 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175694 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175695 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175698 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175699 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175700 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175701 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175703 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175705 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175706 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175707 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175708 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175709 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175710 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175712 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175714 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175715 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175716 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175717 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175718 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175719 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175720 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175721 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175722 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175723 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -6 reading relation 148175724 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175725 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175726 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175727 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175728 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175729 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175730 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175732 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -9 reading relation 148175735 Wed Dec 6 23:37:08 2017 error -11 reading relation 148175738 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -1 reading relation 149092529 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 149092531 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092535 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092537 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092538 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 149092545 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092548 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -1 reading relation 149092549 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -9 reading relation 149092551 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092552 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092554 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -9 reading relation 149092558 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092560 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -9 reading relation 149092566 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -9 reading relation 149092568 Wed Dec 6 23:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 149092569 Thu Dec 7 00:07:01 2017 error -11 reading relation 322832503 Thu Dec 7 00:07:01 2017 error -6 reading relation 322832504 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666192 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -9 reading relation 708666195 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -1 reading relation 708666196 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666197 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666200 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666201 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666206 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666207 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666213 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666214 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666215 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666216 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666217 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666220 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666221 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666223 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666224 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666274 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666279 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666282 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666284 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666292 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666293 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666298 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666302 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666303 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666307 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666311 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666312 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666313 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666314 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666315 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666319 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666325 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666326 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666328 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666329 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666330 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666332 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666333 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666338 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666339 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -9 reading relation 708666345 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666346 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666367 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666371 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -9 reading relation 708666376 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -1 reading relation 708666377 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -9 reading relation 708666380 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666389 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666395 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666396 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666397 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666399 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -11 reading relation 708666405 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -1 reading relation 708666406 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666444 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666465 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666469 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666476 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666480 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -1 reading relation 708666498 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666500 Thu Dec 7 01:12:36 2017 error -6 reading relation 708666505 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825092 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825094 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825096 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825097 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825098 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825099 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825101 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825102 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825103 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825105 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825107 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825108 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825109 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825110 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825113 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825114 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825119 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825120 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825126 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825131 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825132 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825133 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825136 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825140 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825144 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825145 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825149 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825151 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825154 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825157 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825164 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825166 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825168 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825170 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825191 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825193 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825196 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825204 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825211 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825213 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825214 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825216 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825217 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825222 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825224 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825225 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825227 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825230 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825232 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825233 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825243 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825254 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825257 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825259 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825261 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825262 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825263 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825270 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825272 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825277 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825279 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825280 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825281 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825283 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825285 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825286 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825287 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825288 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825289 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825290 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825292 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825296 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825298 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825299 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825300 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -1 reading relation 937825302 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825303 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -9 reading relation 937825307 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825309 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -1 reading relation 937825313 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825318 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825321 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825322 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825323 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825327 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825328 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825329 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825331 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825332 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825333 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825334 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825338 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825339 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825347 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825348 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825349 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825351 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825353 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825354 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825357 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825358 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825362 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825376 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825377 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825389 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825390 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825392 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825419 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825421 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825429 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825436 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825437 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825441 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825442 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825443 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825444 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825445 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825446 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825447 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825448 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825454 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825455 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825456 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -11 reading relation 937825457 Thu Dec 7 01:53:15 2017 error -6 reading relation 937825461 Thu Dec 7 02:12:31 2017 error -1 reading relation 1047805187 Thu Dec 7 02:12:31 2017 error -11 reading relation 1047805215 Thu Dec 7 02:36:28 2017 error -11 reading relation 1186278032 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -15 reading relation 1190918722 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -1 reading relation 1190918728 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918730 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918731 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918732 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918733 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918737 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918739 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 1190918740 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 1190918741 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918742 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 1190918745 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918746 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918749 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918750 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918752 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918753 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918755 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 1190918756 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918757 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918758 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918759 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918760 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918764 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918765 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918766 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918768 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918769 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918772 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 1190918774 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918776 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918777 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918778 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918779 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918780 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918782 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918783 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918785 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918787 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918788 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918789 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -6 reading relation 1190918791 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918793 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918794 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918796 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918798 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918799 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918800 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918801 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918802 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918805 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918806 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918807 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918808 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918809 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918810 Thu Dec 7 02:37:18 2017 error -11 reading relation 1190918811 Thu Dec 7 02:38:58 2017 error -6 reading relation 1200603661 Thu Dec 7 02:46:15 2017 skipped 4768 relations with b > 2^32 Thu Dec 7 02:46:15 2017 skipped 860 relations with composite factors Thu Dec 7 02:46:15 2017 found 365663781 hash collisions in 1241867008 relations Thu Dec 7 02:46:42 2017 added 1219004 free relations Thu Dec 7 02:46:42 2017 commencing duplicate removal, pass 2 Thu Dec 7 03:02:13 2017 found 320180234 duplicates and 922905778 unique relations Thu Dec 7 03:02:13 2017 memory use: 8780.0 MB Thu Dec 7 03:02:14 2017 reading ideals above 999882752 Thu Dec 7 03:02:14 2017 commencing singleton removal, initial pass Thu Dec 7 05:04:55 2017 memory use: 11024.0 MB Thu Dec 7 05:04:55 2017 reading all ideals from disk Thu Dec 7 05:05:23 2017 memory use: 14193.0 MB Thu Dec 7 05:06:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 05:07:16 2017 begin with 922905778 relations and 600460915 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 05:15:56 2017 reduce to 732694117 relations and 398081307 ideals in 10 passes Thu Dec 7 05:15:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 36 Thu Dec 7 05:16:54 2017 reading ideals above 720000 Thu Dec 7 05:16:55 2017 commencing singleton removal, initial pass Thu Dec 7 07:38:30 2017 memory use: 11024.0 MB Thu Dec 7 07:38:31 2017 reading large ideals from disk Thu Dec 7 07:47:21 2017 keeping 439952447 ideals with weight <= 20, target excess is 59800713 Thu Dec 7 07:58:50 2017 memory use: 19414.4 MB Thu Dec 7 07:58:50 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 07:59:16 2017 begin with 732694117 relations and 439952447 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:04:05 2017 reduce to 732625472 relations and 439883800 ideals in 8 passes Thu Dec 7 08:04:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:07:40 2017 removing 10204554 relations and 8204554 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:07:51 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:08:14 2017 begin with 722420918 relations and 439883800 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:12:09 2017 reduce to 722291573 relations and 431549388 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 08:12:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:15:02 2017 removing 7861409 relations and 5861409 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:15:14 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:15:40 2017 begin with 714430164 relations and 431549388 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:19:02 2017 reduce to 714341317 relations and 425598795 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 08:19:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:21:50 2017 removing 7100127 relations and 5100127 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:22:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:22:23 2017 begin with 707241190 relations and 425598795 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:25:41 2017 reduce to 707162805 relations and 420420018 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 08:25:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:28:26 2017 removing 6741038 relations and 4741038 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:28:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:28:59 2017 begin with 700421767 relations and 420420018 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:32:17 2017 reduce to 700352515 relations and 415609487 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 08:32:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:35:00 2017 removing 6449228 relations and 4449228 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:35:10 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:35:32 2017 begin with 693903287 relations and 415609487 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:38:33 2017 reduce to 693838828 relations and 411095580 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 08:38:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:41:24 2017 removing 6289192 relations and 4289192 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:41:34 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:41:54 2017 begin with 687549636 relations and 411095580 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:44:58 2017 reduce to 687488521 relations and 406745045 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 08:44:58 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:47:47 2017 removing 6121462 relations and 4121462 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:47:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:48:21 2017 begin with 681367059 relations and 406745045 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:50:51 2017 reduce to 681310109 relations and 402566412 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 08:50:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 08:53:53 2017 removing 5955232 relations and 3955232 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 08:54:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 08:54:26 2017 begin with 675354877 relations and 402566412 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 08:57:33 2017 reduce to 675297961 relations and 398554047 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 08:57:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:00:13 2017 removing 5919532 relations and 3919532 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:00:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:00:47 2017 begin with 669378429 relations and 398554047 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:03:33 2017 reduce to 669324555 relations and 394580443 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:03:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:06:46 2017 removing 5857204 relations and 3857204 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:06:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:07:16 2017 begin with 663467351 relations and 394580443 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:09:34 2017 reduce to 663417065 relations and 390672733 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 09:09:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:12:52 2017 removing 5729203 relations and 3729203 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:13:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:13:21 2017 begin with 657687862 relations and 390672733 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:15:47 2017 reduce to 657634841 relations and 386890287 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:15:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:18:04 2017 removing 5699489 relations and 3699489 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:18:14 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:18:32 2017 begin with 651935352 relations and 386890287 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:21:04 2017 reduce to 651886012 relations and 383141243 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:21:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:23:24 2017 removing 5601721 relations and 3601721 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:23:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:23:52 2017 begin with 646284291 relations and 383141243 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:25:57 2017 reduce to 646233039 relations and 379488063 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 09:25:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:28:16 2017 removing 5627445 relations and 3627445 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:28:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:28:42 2017 begin with 640605594 relations and 379488063 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:31:11 2017 reduce to 640557774 relations and 375812586 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:31:11 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:33:35 2017 removing 5569678 relations and 3569678 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:33:43 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:34:02 2017 begin with 634988096 relations and 375812586 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:36:34 2017 reduce to 634942549 relations and 372197145 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:36:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:39:07 2017 removing 5509996 relations and 3509996 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:39:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:39:34 2017 begin with 629432553 relations and 372197145 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:42:02 2017 reduce to 629385177 relations and 368639531 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:42:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:44:19 2017 removing 5396373 relations and 3396373 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:44:28 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:44:46 2017 begin with 623988804 relations and 368639531 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:47:10 2017 reduce to 623936258 relations and 365190330 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 09:47:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:49:27 2017 removing 5533173 relations and 3533173 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:49:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:49:52 2017 begin with 618403085 relations and 365190330 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:51:53 2017 reduce to 618358862 relations and 361612689 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 09:51:53 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:54:08 2017 removing 5346370 relations and 3346370 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:54:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:54:32 2017 begin with 613012492 relations and 361612689 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 09:56:32 2017 reduce to 612966295 relations and 358219835 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 09:56:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 09:58:47 2017 removing 5442146 relations and 3442146 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 09:58:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 09:59:11 2017 begin with 607524149 relations and 358219835 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:02:04 2017 reduce to 607480330 relations and 354733606 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 10:02:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:04:18 2017 removing 5383130 relations and 3383130 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:04:26 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:04:44 2017 begin with 602097200 relations and 354733606 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:06:50 2017 reduce to 602054264 relations and 351307283 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 10:06:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:09:04 2017 removing 5242655 relations and 3242655 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:09:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:09:31 2017 begin with 596811609 relations and 351307283 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:11:33 2017 reduce to 596758032 relations and 348010748 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 10:11:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:13:41 2017 removing 5302231 relations and 3302231 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:13:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:14:08 2017 begin with 591455801 relations and 348010748 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:16:09 2017 reduce to 591406036 relations and 344658467 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 10:16:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:18:21 2017 removing 5271602 relations and 3271602 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:18:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:18:47 2017 begin with 586134434 relations and 344658467 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:21:17 2017 reduce to 586088790 relations and 341340920 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:21:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:23:25 2017 removing 5229248 relations and 3229248 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:23:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:23:47 2017 begin with 580859542 relations and 341340920 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:25:37 2017 reduce to 580810410 relations and 338062175 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 10:25:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:27:41 2017 removing 5331966 relations and 3331966 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:27:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:28:05 2017 begin with 575478444 relations and 338062175 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:30:17 2017 reduce to 575433797 relations and 334685223 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:30:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:32:16 2017 removing 5269810 relations and 3269810 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:32:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:32:38 2017 begin with 570163987 relations and 334685223 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:34:45 2017 reduce to 570119845 relations and 331370939 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:34:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:36:41 2017 removing 5197674 relations and 3197674 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:36:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:37:03 2017 begin with 564922171 relations and 331370939 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:39:05 2017 reduce to 564879857 relations and 328130628 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:39:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:40:56 2017 removing 5247283 relations and 3247283 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:41:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:41:16 2017 begin with 559632574 relations and 328130628 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:43:20 2017 reduce to 559587687 relations and 324838101 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:43:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:45:11 2017 removing 5197269 relations and 3197269 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:45:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:45:36 2017 begin with 554390418 relations and 324838101 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:47:49 2017 reduce to 554345961 relations and 321596049 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:47:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:49:45 2017 removing 5169357 relations and 3169357 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:49:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:50:09 2017 begin with 549176604 relations and 321596049 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:52:23 2017 reduce to 549131796 relations and 318381515 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:52:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:54:12 2017 removing 5002353 relations and 3002353 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:54:20 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:54:34 2017 begin with 544129443 relations and 318381515 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 10:56:35 2017 reduce to 544073699 relations and 315322939 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 10:56:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 10:58:23 2017 removing 5108426 relations and 3108426 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 10:58:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 10:58:45 2017 begin with 538965273 relations and 315322939 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:00:52 2017 reduce to 538912092 relations and 312160921 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:00:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:02:42 2017 removing 5141127 relations and 3141127 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:02:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:03:06 2017 begin with 533770965 relations and 312160921 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:04:49 2017 reduce to 533723633 relations and 308972034 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 11:04:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:06:26 2017 removing 5128447 relations and 3128447 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:06:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:06:44 2017 begin with 528595186 relations and 308972034 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:08:07 2017 reduce to 528550744 relations and 305798756 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 11:08:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:09:41 2017 removing 5107137 relations and 3107137 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:09:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:09:59 2017 begin with 523443607 relations and 305798756 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:11:33 2017 reduce to 523398929 relations and 302646567 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:11:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:13:06 2017 removing 5157467 relations and 3157467 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:13:12 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:13:27 2017 begin with 518241462 relations and 302646567 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:15:02 2017 reduce to 518197391 relations and 299444616 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:15:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:16:34 2017 removing 5112865 relations and 3112865 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:16:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:16:53 2017 begin with 513084526 relations and 299444616 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:18:40 2017 reduce to 513040483 relations and 296287339 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:18:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:20:25 2017 removing 5109371 relations and 3109371 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:20:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:20:45 2017 begin with 507931112 relations and 296287339 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:22:30 2017 reduce to 507886499 relations and 293132982 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:22:30 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:24:10 2017 removing 4911374 relations and 2911374 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:24:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:24:29 2017 begin with 502975125 relations and 293132982 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:26:16 2017 reduce to 502919753 relations and 290165722 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:26:16 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:27:53 2017 removing 5079874 relations and 3079874 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:27:59 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:28:11 2017 begin with 497839879 relations and 290165722 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:29:44 2017 reduce to 497794631 relations and 287040170 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:29:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:31:16 2017 removing 5091671 relations and 3091671 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:31:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:31:35 2017 begin with 492702960 relations and 287040170 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:33:12 2017 reduce to 492655536 relations and 283900556 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:33:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:34:43 2017 removing 5066856 relations and 3066856 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:34:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:35:00 2017 begin with 487588680 relations and 283900556 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:36:48 2017 reduce to 487543014 relations and 280787581 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:36:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:38:21 2017 removing 5053070 relations and 3053070 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:38:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:38:38 2017 begin with 482489944 relations and 280787581 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:39:56 2017 reduce to 482445096 relations and 277689220 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 11:39:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:41:31 2017 removing 5010287 relations and 3010287 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:41:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:41:51 2017 begin with 477434809 relations and 277689220 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:43:35 2017 reduce to 477385535 relations and 274629167 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:43:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:45:08 2017 removing 4880536 relations and 2880536 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:45:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:45:28 2017 begin with 472504999 relations and 274629167 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:47:13 2017 reduce to 472448541 relations and 271691564 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:47:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:48:45 2017 removing 4974228 relations and 2974228 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:48:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:49:05 2017 begin with 467474313 relations and 271691564 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:50:56 2017 reduce to 467420731 relations and 268663170 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 11:50:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:52:25 2017 removing 5014279 relations and 3014279 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:52:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:52:43 2017 begin with 462406452 relations and 268663170 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:54:05 2017 reduce to 462359289 relations and 265601220 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 11:54:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:55:33 2017 removing 5024243 relations and 3024243 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:55:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:55:52 2017 begin with 457335046 relations and 265601220 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 11:57:33 2017 reduce to 457290784 relations and 262532190 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 11:57:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 11:59:00 2017 removing 5026736 relations and 3026736 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 11:59:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 11:59:19 2017 begin with 452264048 relations and 262532190 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:01:04 2017 reduce to 452216954 relations and 259457859 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:01:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:02:31 2017 removing 4954203 relations and 2954203 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:02:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:02:49 2017 begin with 447262751 relations and 259457859 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:04:24 2017 reduce to 447210721 relations and 256451148 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:04:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:05:45 2017 removing 5014376 relations and 3014376 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:05:51 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:06:02 2017 begin with 442196345 relations and 256451148 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:07:17 2017 reduce to 442151591 relations and 253391494 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 12:07:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:08:41 2017 removing 5025615 relations and 3025615 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:08:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:08:58 2017 begin with 437125976 relations and 253391494 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:10:24 2017 reduce to 437079482 relations and 250318864 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:10:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:11:39 2017 removing 4948182 relations and 2948182 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:11:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:11:53 2017 begin with 432131300 relations and 250318864 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:13:08 2017 reduce to 432079404 relations and 247318206 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:13:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:14:23 2017 removing 4954517 relations and 2954517 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:14:28 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:14:38 2017 begin with 427124887 relations and 247318206 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:15:59 2017 reduce to 427078083 relations and 244316370 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:15:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:17:17 2017 removing 4853120 relations and 2853120 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:17:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:17:32 2017 begin with 422224963 relations and 244316370 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:19:04 2017 reduce to 422173060 relations and 241410736 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 12:19:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:20:19 2017 removing 4913138 relations and 2913138 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:20:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:20:33 2017 begin with 417259922 relations and 241410736 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:21:50 2017 reduce to 417205410 relations and 238442463 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:21:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:23:06 2017 removing 4921548 relations and 2921548 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:23:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:23:20 2017 begin with 412283862 relations and 238442463 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:24:38 2017 reduce to 412229883 relations and 235466329 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:24:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:25:54 2017 removing 4992093 relations and 2992093 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:26:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:26:09 2017 begin with 407237790 relations and 235466329 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:27:25 2017 reduce to 407190553 relations and 232426431 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:27:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:28:39 2017 removing 4901854 relations and 2901854 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:28:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:28:53 2017 begin with 402288699 relations and 232426431 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:30:00 2017 reduce to 402228718 relations and 229463879 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 12:30:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:31:17 2017 removing 4981974 relations and 2981974 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:31:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:31:33 2017 begin with 397246744 relations and 229463879 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:32:56 2017 reduce to 397200400 relations and 226434998 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:32:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:34:13 2017 removing 4923436 relations and 2923436 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:34:19 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:34:28 2017 begin with 392276964 relations and 226434998 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:35:49 2017 reduce to 392217150 relations and 223451033 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:35:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:37:08 2017 removing 4911578 relations and 2911578 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:37:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:37:22 2017 begin with 387305572 relations and 223451033 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:38:45 2017 reduce to 387251714 relations and 220484909 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:38:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:39:58 2017 removing 4852982 relations and 2852982 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:40:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:40:14 2017 begin with 382398732 relations and 220484909 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:41:23 2017 reduce to 382338774 relations and 217571118 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:41:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:42:32 2017 removing 4862460 relations and 2862460 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:42:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:42:46 2017 begin with 377476314 relations and 217571118 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:44:12 2017 reduce to 377417085 relations and 214648646 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 12:44:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:45:21 2017 removing 4937784 relations and 2937784 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:45:25 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:45:35 2017 begin with 372479301 relations and 214648646 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:46:46 2017 reduce to 372424394 relations and 211655258 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:46:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:47:56 2017 removing 4967878 relations and 2967878 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:48:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:48:10 2017 begin with 367456516 relations and 211655258 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:49:23 2017 reduce to 367405913 relations and 208636120 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:49:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:50:34 2017 removing 4894904 relations and 2894904 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:50:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:50:48 2017 begin with 362511009 relations and 208636120 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:52:00 2017 reduce to 362456024 relations and 205685501 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:52:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:53:08 2017 removing 4898692 relations and 2898692 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:53:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:53:21 2017 begin with 357557332 relations and 205685501 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:54:34 2017 reduce to 357505451 relations and 202734227 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:54:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:55:44 2017 removing 4872611 relations and 2872611 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:55:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:55:57 2017 begin with 352632840 relations and 202734227 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:57:03 2017 reduce to 352572581 relations and 199800542 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:57:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 12:58:08 2017 removing 4988743 relations and 2988743 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 12:58:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 12:58:20 2017 begin with 347583838 relations and 199800542 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 12:59:30 2017 reduce to 347532745 relations and 196760033 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 12:59:30 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:00:36 2017 removing 4926202 relations and 2926202 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:00:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:00:49 2017 begin with 342606543 relations and 196760033 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:02:01 2017 reduce to 342553633 relations and 193780233 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:02:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:03:07 2017 removing 4907752 relations and 2907752 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:03:12 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:03:20 2017 begin with 337645881 relations and 193780233 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:04:26 2017 reduce to 337592821 relations and 190818734 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:04:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:05:27 2017 removing 4908183 relations and 2908183 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:05:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:05:40 2017 begin with 332684638 relations and 190818734 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:06:43 2017 reduce to 332630483 relations and 187855743 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:06:43 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:07:39 2017 removing 4861366 relations and 2861366 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:07:43 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:07:51 2017 begin with 327769117 relations and 187855743 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:08:59 2017 reduce to 327720296 relations and 184944973 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:08:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:09:56 2017 removing 4873957 relations and 2873957 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:10:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:10:07 2017 begin with 322846339 relations and 184944973 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:11:03 2017 reduce to 322792670 relations and 182016667 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:11:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:11:56 2017 removing 4919667 relations and 2919667 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:12:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:12:06 2017 begin with 317873003 relations and 182016667 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:13:02 2017 reduce to 317820753 relations and 179044130 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:13:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:13:54 2017 removing 4928942 relations and 2928942 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:13:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:14:05 2017 begin with 312891811 relations and 179044130 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:14:58 2017 reduce to 312841758 relations and 176064591 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:14:58 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:15:53 2017 removing 4922716 relations and 2922716 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:15:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:16:05 2017 begin with 307919042 relations and 176064591 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:16:58 2017 reduce to 307866770 relations and 173089049 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:16:58 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:17:50 2017 removing 4880120 relations and 2880120 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:17:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:18:01 2017 begin with 302986650 relations and 173089049 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:18:57 2017 reduce to 302934356 relations and 170156089 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:18:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:19:48 2017 removing 4924567 relations and 2924567 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:19:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:19:58 2017 begin with 298009789 relations and 170156089 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:20:59 2017 reduce to 297945733 relations and 167166776 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:20:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 13:21:50 2017 removing 4850995 relations and 2850995 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:21:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:22:01 2017 begin with 293094738 relations and 167166776 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:22:56 2017 reduce to 293017754 relations and 164237919 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:22:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:23:45 2017 removing 4811568 relations and 2811568 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:23:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:23:55 2017 begin with 288206186 relations and 164237919 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:24:56 2017 reduce to 288124226 relations and 161343542 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:24:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:25:47 2017 removing 4788685 relations and 2788685 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:25:51 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:25:57 2017 begin with 283335541 relations and 161343542 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:26:51 2017 reduce to 283250473 relations and 158468758 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:26:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:27:41 2017 removing 4771552 relations and 2771552 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:27:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:27:52 2017 begin with 278478921 relations and 158468758 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:28:54 2017 reduce to 278387388 relations and 155604518 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:28:54 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:29:44 2017 removing 4745630 relations and 2745630 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:29:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:29:55 2017 begin with 273641758 relations and 155604518 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:30:47 2017 reduce to 273544032 relations and 152759679 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:30:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:31:38 2017 removing 4758169 relations and 2758169 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:31:42 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:31:48 2017 begin with 268785863 relations and 152759679 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:32:46 2017 reduce to 268690411 relations and 149904292 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:32:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:33:33 2017 removing 4875941 relations and 2875941 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:33:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:33:43 2017 begin with 263814470 relations and 149904292 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:34:34 2017 reduce to 263720446 relations and 146932505 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:34:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Thu Dec 7 13:35:22 2017 removing 4904585 relations and 2904585 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:35:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:35:32 2017 begin with 258815861 relations and 146932505 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:36:18 2017 reduce to 258728404 relations and 143938678 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:36:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:37:04 2017 removing 4888436 relations and 2888436 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:37:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:37:13 2017 begin with 253839968 relations and 143938678 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:38:10 2017 reduce to 253759404 relations and 140967900 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:38:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:38:57 2017 removing 4933124 relations and 2933124 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:39:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:39:05 2017 begin with 248826280 relations and 140967900 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:39:51 2017 reduce to 248731675 relations and 137938080 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:39:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:40:36 2017 removing 4884177 relations and 2884177 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:40:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:40:44 2017 begin with 243847498 relations and 137938080 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:41:26 2017 reduce to 243757571 relations and 134962121 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:41:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:42:08 2017 removing 4955873 relations and 2955873 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:42:12 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:42:17 2017 begin with 238801698 relations and 134962121 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:43:08 2017 reduce to 238706167 relations and 131908709 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:43:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:43:50 2017 removing 4929257 relations and 2929257 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:43:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:43:59 2017 begin with 233776910 relations and 131908709 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:44:45 2017 reduce to 233683551 relations and 128884161 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:44:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:45:27 2017 removing 4940035 relations and 2940035 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:45:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:45:35 2017 begin with 228743516 relations and 128884161 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:46:23 2017 reduce to 228663238 relations and 125862129 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:46:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:47:03 2017 removing 4990524 relations and 2990524 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:47:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:47:12 2017 begin with 223672714 relations and 125862129 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:48:02 2017 reduce to 223577750 relations and 122774699 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:48:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 13:48:41 2017 removing 4994272 relations and 2994272 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:48:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:48:49 2017 begin with 218583478 relations and 122774699 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:49:34 2017 reduce to 218504102 relations and 119699440 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:49:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:50:14 2017 removing 4961102 relations and 2961102 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:50:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:50:21 2017 begin with 213543000 relations and 119699440 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:51:04 2017 reduce to 213435665 relations and 116629044 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:51:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:51:44 2017 removing 4847526 relations and 2847526 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:51:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:51:52 2017 begin with 208588139 relations and 116629044 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:52:35 2017 reduce to 208470608 relations and 113661861 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:52:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:53:13 2017 removing 4802622 relations and 2802622 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:53:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:53:21 2017 begin with 203667986 relations and 113661861 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:53:57 2017 reduce to 203545001 relations and 110733886 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 13:53:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:54:36 2017 removing 4882933 relations and 2882933 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:54:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:54:43 2017 begin with 198662068 relations and 110733886 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:55:25 2017 reduce to 198534649 relations and 107721123 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:55:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:56:03 2017 removing 4902725 relations and 2902725 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:56:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:56:10 2017 begin with 193631924 relations and 107721123 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:56:54 2017 reduce to 193500515 relations and 104684564 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:56:54 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:57:28 2017 removing 4853823 relations and 2853823 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:57:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:57:35 2017 begin with 188646692 relations and 104684564 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:58:15 2017 reduce to 188512128 relations and 101693774 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:58:15 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 13:58:53 2017 removing 4855099 relations and 2855099 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 13:58:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 13:58:59 2017 begin with 183657029 relations and 101693774 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 13:59:37 2017 reduce to 183531334 relations and 98710759 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 13:59:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 14:00:13 2017 removing 5036525 relations and 3036525 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:00:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:00:19 2017 begin with 178494809 relations and 98710759 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:00:48 2017 reduce to 178401905 relations and 95579727 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 14:00:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Thu Dec 7 14:01:21 2017 removing 5083150 relations and 3083150 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:01:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:01:27 2017 begin with 173318755 relations and 95579727 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:02:01 2017 reduce to 173199302 relations and 92375041 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 14:02:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Thu Dec 7 14:02:36 2017 removing 5004606 relations and 3004606 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:02:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:02:42 2017 begin with 168194696 relations and 92375041 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:03:10 2017 reduce to 168060328 relations and 89233797 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 14:03:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Thu Dec 7 14:03:41 2017 removing 4929007 relations and 2929007 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:03:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:03:47 2017 begin with 163131321 relations and 89233797 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:04:29 2017 reduce to 162984302 relations and 86155070 ideals in 9 passes Thu Dec 7 14:04:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Thu Dec 7 14:05:00 2017 removing 4853434 relations and 2853434 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:05:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:05:07 2017 begin with 158130868 relations and 86155070 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:05:35 2017 reduce to 157969434 relations and 83136472 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 14:05:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Thu Dec 7 14:06:04 2017 removing 5090536 relations and 3090536 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:06:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:06:10 2017 begin with 152878898 relations and 83136472 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:06:40 2017 reduce to 152735998 relations and 79899236 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 14:06:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Thu Dec 7 14:07:09 2017 removing 5102623 relations and 3102623 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:07:12 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:07:16 2017 begin with 147633375 relations and 79899236 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:07:48 2017 reduce to 147480464 relations and 76639586 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 14:07:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Thu Dec 7 14:08:16 2017 removing 3603622 relations and 2131572 ideals in 1472050 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:08:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:08:20 2017 begin with 143876842 relations and 76639586 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:08:49 2017 reduce to 143764491 relations and 74392975 ideals in 8 passes Thu Dec 7 14:08:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 0 large ideals: 21191854 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 1 large ideals: 61870753 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 2 large ideals: 49008825 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 3 large ideals: 10640618 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 4 large ideals: 974274 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 5 large ideals: 74858 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 6 large ideals: 3237 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 relations with 7+ large ideals: 72 Thu Dec 7 14:09:21 2017 commencing 2-way merge Thu Dec 7 14:09:58 2017 reduce to 95205547 relation sets and 25834031 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:09:58 2017 commencing full merge Thu Dec 7 14:12:17 2017 memory use: 3098.1 MB Thu Dec 7 14:12:26 2017 found 69371465 cycles, need 59800913 Thu Dec 7 14:12:43 2017 weight of 59800913 cycles is about 2287039339 (38.24/cycle) Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 1 relations: 21191854 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 2 relations: 11666426 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 3 relations: 10546701 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 4 relations: 8465030 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 5 relations: 6154761 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 6 relations: 1776059 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 7 relations: 82 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 8 relations: 0 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 9 relations: 0 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 10+ relations: 0 Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 heaviest cycle: 7 relations Thu Dec 7 14:12:45 2017 matrix not dense enough, retrying Thu Dec 7 14:12:52 2017 reading large ideals from disk Thu Dec 7 14:21:46 2017 keeping 453759157 ideals with weight <= 25, target excess is 45994003 Thu Dec 7 14:31:16 2017 memory use: 19414.4 MB Thu Dec 7 14:31:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:31:38 2017 begin with 732694117 relations and 453759157 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:35:54 2017 reduce to 732625472 relations and 453690510 ideals in 8 passes Thu Dec 7 14:35:54 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 14:38:46 2017 removing 10403451 relations and 8403451 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:38:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:39:21 2017 begin with 722222021 relations and 453690510 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:42:36 2017 reduce to 722096836 relations and 445161388 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 14:42:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 14:45:22 2017 removing 8026622 relations and 6026622 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:45:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:45:56 2017 begin with 714070214 relations and 445161388 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:49:00 2017 reduce to 713983350 relations and 439047580 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 14:49:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 14:51:42 2017 removing 7249021 relations and 5249021 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:51:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:52:14 2017 begin with 706734329 relations and 439047580 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 14:55:21 2017 reduce to 706658110 relations and 433722102 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 14:55:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 14:58:01 2017 removing 6852265 relations and 4852265 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 14:58:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 14:58:33 2017 begin with 699805845 relations and 433722102 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:01:26 2017 reduce to 699738272 relations and 428802043 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:01:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:04:03 2017 removing 6560732 relations and 4560732 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:04:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:04:34 2017 begin with 693177540 relations and 428802043 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:07:38 2017 reduce to 693114713 relations and 424178273 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:07:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:10:13 2017 removing 6353160 relations and 4353160 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:10:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:10:42 2017 begin with 686761553 relations and 424178273 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:13:13 2017 reduce to 686701386 relations and 419764721 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 15:13:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:15:48 2017 removing 6198984 relations and 4198984 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:15:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:16:19 2017 begin with 680502402 relations and 419764721 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:19:14 2017 reduce to 680445344 relations and 415508464 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:19:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:21:45 2017 removing 6069309 relations and 4069309 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:21:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:22:16 2017 begin with 674376035 relations and 415508464 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:24:38 2017 reduce to 674321960 relations and 411384900 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 15:24:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:27:08 2017 removing 5958136 relations and 3958136 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:27:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:27:40 2017 begin with 668363824 relations and 411384900 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:30:30 2017 reduce to 668309457 relations and 407372185 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:30:30 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:33:06 2017 removing 5902748 relations and 3902748 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:33:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:33:35 2017 begin with 662406709 relations and 407372185 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:35:44 2017 reduce to 662355802 relations and 403418340 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 15:35:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:38:08 2017 removing 5813443 relations and 3813443 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:38:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:38:37 2017 begin with 656542359 relations and 403418340 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:41:12 2017 reduce to 656492147 relations and 399554471 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:41:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:43:39 2017 removing 5773478 relations and 3773478 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:43:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:44:10 2017 begin with 650718669 relations and 399554471 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:46:44 2017 reduce to 650670372 relations and 395732494 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:46:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:49:09 2017 removing 5703561 relations and 3703561 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:49:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:49:37 2017 begin with 644966811 relations and 395732494 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:52:16 2017 reduce to 644918851 relations and 391980755 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:52:16 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:54:39 2017 removing 5610914 relations and 3610914 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 15:54:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 15:55:06 2017 begin with 639307937 relations and 391980755 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 15:57:38 2017 reduce to 639258833 relations and 388320540 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 15:57:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 15:59:57 2017 removing 5614801 relations and 3614801 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:00:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:00:28 2017 begin with 633644032 relations and 388320540 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:03:07 2017 reduce to 633597868 relations and 384659338 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 16:03:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:05:28 2017 removing 5552291 relations and 3552291 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:05:36 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:05:57 2017 begin with 628045577 relations and 384659338 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:08:36 2017 reduce to 627999048 relations and 381060294 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 16:08:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:10:50 2017 removing 5488986 relations and 3488986 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:10:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:11:15 2017 begin with 622510062 relations and 381060294 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:14:25 2017 reduce to 622461526 relations and 377522520 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 16:14:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:17:37 2017 removing 5509411 relations and 3509411 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:17:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:18:20 2017 begin with 616952115 relations and 377522520 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:22:07 2017 reduce to 616906478 relations and 373967233 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 16:22:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:25:21 2017 removing 5458716 relations and 3458716 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:25:28 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:26:03 2017 begin with 611447762 relations and 373967233 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:29:05 2017 reduce to 611403288 relations and 370463774 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 16:29:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:32:07 2017 removing 5400443 relations and 3400443 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:32:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:32:43 2017 begin with 606002845 relations and 370463774 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:35:22 2017 reduce to 605957112 relations and 367017335 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 16:35:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:38:34 2017 removing 5414661 relations and 3414661 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:38:42 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:39:10 2017 begin with 600542451 relations and 367017335 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:41:18 2017 reduce to 600497377 relations and 363557310 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 16:41:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:43:58 2017 removing 5348253 relations and 3348253 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:44:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:44:49 2017 begin with 595149124 relations and 363557310 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:47:18 2017 reduce to 595102673 relations and 360162322 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 16:47:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:50:54 2017 removing 5361482 relations and 3361482 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:51:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:51:41 2017 begin with 589741191 relations and 360162322 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 16:54:28 2017 reduce to 589695776 relations and 356755131 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 16:54:28 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 16:58:12 2017 removing 5328589 relations and 3328589 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 16:58:19 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 16:59:02 2017 begin with 584367187 relations and 356755131 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:01:10 2017 reduce to 584322280 relations and 353381325 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:01:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:04:34 2017 removing 5263312 relations and 3263312 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:04:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:04:58 2017 begin with 579058968 relations and 353381325 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:07:11 2017 reduce to 579013089 relations and 350071794 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:07:11 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:09:10 2017 removing 5312239 relations and 3312239 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:09:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:09:34 2017 begin with 573700850 relations and 350071794 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:11:40 2017 reduce to 573656494 relations and 346714890 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:11:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:13:39 2017 removing 5290667 relations and 3290667 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:13:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:14:02 2017 begin with 568365827 relations and 346714890 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:16:20 2017 reduce to 568322828 relations and 343380915 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:16:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:18:24 2017 removing 5257295 relations and 3257295 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:18:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:18:49 2017 begin with 563065533 relations and 343380915 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:20:37 2017 reduce to 563022619 relations and 340080355 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:20:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:22:35 2017 removing 5185053 relations and 3185053 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:22:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:22:59 2017 begin with 557837566 relations and 340080355 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:24:52 2017 reduce to 557789665 relations and 336847065 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:24:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:26:48 2017 removing 5211380 relations and 3211380 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:26:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:27:11 2017 begin with 552578285 relations and 336847065 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:29:03 2017 reduce to 552532082 relations and 333589113 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:29:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:31:03 2017 removing 5194856 relations and 3194856 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:31:10 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:31:26 2017 begin with 547337226 relations and 333589113 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:33:37 2017 reduce to 547292335 relations and 330349008 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:33:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:35:34 2017 removing 5141937 relations and 3141937 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:35:42 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:35:56 2017 begin with 542150398 relations and 330349008 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:37:41 2017 reduce to 542103057 relations and 327159331 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:37:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:39:37 2017 removing 5170779 relations and 3170779 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:39:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:40:02 2017 begin with 536932278 relations and 327159331 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:41:55 2017 reduce to 536884599 relations and 323940470 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:41:55 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:43:43 2017 removing 5174023 relations and 3174023 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:43:50 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:44:04 2017 begin with 531710576 relations and 323940470 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:45:44 2017 reduce to 531665456 relations and 320720950 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 17:45:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:47:28 2017 removing 5160967 relations and 3160967 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:47:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:47:48 2017 begin with 526504489 relations and 320720950 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:49:44 2017 reduce to 526459960 relations and 317515067 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:49:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:51:27 2017 removing 5131288 relations and 3131288 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:51:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:51:48 2017 begin with 521328672 relations and 317515067 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:53:46 2017 reduce to 521284951 relations and 314339680 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:53:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:55:31 2017 removing 5132604 relations and 3132604 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:55:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:55:52 2017 begin with 516152347 relations and 314339680 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 17:57:46 2017 reduce to 516108816 relations and 311163155 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 17:57:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 17:59:29 2017 removing 5128958 relations and 3128958 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 17:59:36 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 17:59:49 2017 begin with 510979858 relations and 311163155 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:01:38 2017 reduce to 510935044 relations and 307988978 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:01:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:03:20 2017 removing 5097151 relations and 3097151 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:03:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:03:43 2017 begin with 505837893 relations and 307988978 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:05:43 2017 reduce to 505793557 relations and 304847078 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:05:43 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:07:22 2017 removing 5117271 relations and 3117271 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:07:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:07:42 2017 begin with 500676286 relations and 304847078 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:09:12 2017 reduce to 500632199 relations and 301685296 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:09:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:10:45 2017 removing 5065191 relations and 3065191 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:10:51 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:11:04 2017 begin with 495567008 relations and 301685296 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:12:27 2017 reduce to 495521072 relations and 298573734 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:12:27 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:14:00 2017 removing 5048376 relations and 3048376 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:14:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:14:21 2017 begin with 490472696 relations and 298573734 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:15:45 2017 reduce to 490424448 relations and 295476622 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:15:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:17:20 2017 removing 5018195 relations and 3018195 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:17:26 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:17:40 2017 begin with 485406253 relations and 295476622 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:19:05 2017 reduce to 485355680 relations and 292407418 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:19:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:20:37 2017 removing 5034792 relations and 3034792 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:20:43 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:20:57 2017 begin with 480320888 relations and 292407418 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:22:36 2017 reduce to 480273047 relations and 289324328 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:22:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:24:10 2017 removing 5059248 relations and 3059248 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:24:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:24:29 2017 begin with 475213799 relations and 289324328 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:25:56 2017 reduce to 475167632 relations and 286218424 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:25:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:27:27 2017 removing 5011799 relations and 3011799 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:27:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:27:46 2017 begin with 470155833 relations and 286218424 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:29:14 2017 reduce to 470108580 relations and 283158879 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:29:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:30:49 2017 removing 5043568 relations and 3043568 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:30:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:31:07 2017 begin with 465065012 relations and 283158879 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:32:46 2017 reduce to 465019471 relations and 280069296 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:32:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:34:17 2017 removing 5009467 relations and 3009467 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:34:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:34:36 2017 begin with 460010004 relations and 280069296 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:36:12 2017 reduce to 459962579 relations and 277011924 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:36:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:37:43 2017 removing 5038271 relations and 3038271 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:37:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:38:01 2017 begin with 454924308 relations and 277011924 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:39:38 2017 reduce to 454877981 relations and 273926882 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:39:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:41:09 2017 removing 5016513 relations and 3016513 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:41:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:41:28 2017 begin with 449861468 relations and 273926882 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:42:47 2017 reduce to 449814920 relations and 270863322 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:42:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:44:11 2017 removing 5031839 relations and 3031839 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:44:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:44:30 2017 begin with 444783081 relations and 270863322 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:45:47 2017 reduce to 444737001 relations and 267784911 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:45:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:47:11 2017 removing 4994966 relations and 2994966 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:47:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:47:28 2017 begin with 439742035 relations and 267784911 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:49:02 2017 reduce to 439695841 relations and 264743255 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:49:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:50:27 2017 removing 5015947 relations and 3015947 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:50:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:50:45 2017 begin with 434679894 relations and 264743255 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:52:04 2017 reduce to 434632839 relations and 261679736 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 18:52:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:53:28 2017 removing 4898949 relations and 2898949 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:53:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:53:44 2017 begin with 429733890 relations and 261679736 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:55:14 2017 reduce to 429681721 relations and 258728085 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:55:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:56:35 2017 removing 4993864 relations and 2993864 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:56:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:56:52 2017 begin with 424687857 relations and 258728085 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 18:58:15 2017 reduce to 424639577 relations and 255685349 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 18:58:15 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 18:59:39 2017 removing 4973253 relations and 2973253 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 18:59:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 18:59:56 2017 begin with 419666324 relations and 255685349 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:01:24 2017 reduce to 419617360 relations and 252662552 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:01:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 19:02:45 2017 removing 4981881 relations and 2981881 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:02:51 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:03:03 2017 begin with 414635479 relations and 252662552 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:04:38 2017 reduce to 414586635 relations and 249631228 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:04:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 19:06:01 2017 removing 4966620 relations and 2966620 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:06:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:06:18 2017 begin with 409620015 relations and 249631228 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:07:45 2017 reduce to 409571754 relations and 246615772 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:07:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 19:09:03 2017 removing 4969274 relations and 2969274 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:09:10 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:09:20 2017 begin with 404602480 relations and 246615772 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:10:33 2017 reduce to 404552380 relations and 243595789 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:10:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 19:11:53 2017 removing 4952211 relations and 2952211 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:11:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:12:08 2017 begin with 399600169 relations and 243595789 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:13:20 2017 reduce to 399551504 relations and 240594306 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:13:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 19:14:42 2017 removing 4958751 relations and 2958751 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:14:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:14:59 2017 begin with 394592753 relations and 240594306 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:16:10 2017 reduce to 394543313 relations and 237585516 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:16:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Thu Dec 7 19:17:29 2017 removing 4974492 relations and 2974492 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:17:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:17:44 2017 begin with 389568821 relations and 237585516 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:19:05 2017 reduce to 389518905 relations and 234560472 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:19:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:20:24 2017 removing 4883652 relations and 2883652 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:20:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:20:39 2017 begin with 384635253 relations and 234560472 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:21:59 2017 reduce to 384581061 relations and 231621982 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:21:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:23:17 2017 removing 4845303 relations and 2845303 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:23:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:23:33 2017 begin with 379735758 relations and 231621982 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:24:36 2017 reduce to 379676664 relations and 228716853 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:24:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:25:52 2017 removing 4971334 relations and 2971334 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:25:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:26:08 2017 begin with 374705330 relations and 228716853 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:27:12 2017 reduce to 374652335 relations and 225691840 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:27:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:28:26 2017 removing 4924029 relations and 2924029 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:28:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:28:42 2017 begin with 369728306 relations and 225691840 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:30:00 2017 reduce to 369676576 relations and 222715467 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:30:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:31:13 2017 removing 4935679 relations and 2935679 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:31:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:31:27 2017 begin with 364740897 relations and 222715467 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:32:45 2017 reduce to 364689016 relations and 219727260 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:32:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:33:56 2017 removing 4929734 relations and 2929734 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:34:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:34:09 2017 begin with 359759282 relations and 219727260 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:35:23 2017 reduce to 359706957 relations and 216744549 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:35:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:36:32 2017 removing 4920949 relations and 2920949 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:36:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:36:47 2017 begin with 354786008 relations and 216744549 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:38:23 2017 reduce to 354734769 relations and 213771693 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:38:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:39:43 2017 removing 4961277 relations and 2961277 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:39:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:39:59 2017 begin with 349773492 relations and 213771693 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:41:19 2017 reduce to 349722196 relations and 210758446 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:41:19 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:42:29 2017 removing 4891884 relations and 2891884 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:42:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:42:44 2017 begin with 344830312 relations and 210758446 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:44:03 2017 reduce to 344775063 relations and 207810638 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:44:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Thu Dec 7 19:45:13 2017 removing 4884355 relations and 2884355 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:45:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:45:29 2017 begin with 339890708 relations and 207810638 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:46:34 2017 reduce to 339834111 relations and 204868948 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:46:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 19:47:43 2017 removing 4942670 relations and 2942670 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:47:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:47:57 2017 begin with 334891441 relations and 204868948 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:48:57 2017 reduce to 334837142 relations and 201871247 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:48:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 19:50:03 2017 removing 4930300 relations and 2930300 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:50:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:50:16 2017 begin with 329906842 relations and 201871247 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:51:23 2017 reduce to 329854061 relations and 198887402 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:51:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 19:52:25 2017 removing 4914359 relations and 2914359 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:52:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:52:41 2017 begin with 324939702 relations and 198887402 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:53:52 2017 reduce to 324885899 relations and 195918529 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:53:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 19:54:54 2017 removing 4942228 relations and 2942228 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:54:59 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:55:08 2017 begin with 319943671 relations and 195918529 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:56:00 2017 reduce to 319889928 relations and 192921878 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 19:56:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 19:57:01 2017 removing 4880808 relations and 2880808 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:57:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:57:15 2017 begin with 315009120 relations and 192921878 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 19:58:21 2017 reduce to 314947132 relations and 189978316 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 19:58:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 19:59:25 2017 removing 4868963 relations and 2868963 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 19:59:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 19:59:38 2017 begin with 310078169 relations and 189978316 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:00:52 2017 reduce to 310018706 relations and 187049112 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:00:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Thu Dec 7 20:01:52 2017 removing 4928044 relations and 2928044 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:01:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:02:04 2017 begin with 305090662 relations and 187049112 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:02:56 2017 reduce to 305032224 relations and 184061807 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 20:02:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:03:51 2017 removing 4915334 relations and 2915334 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:03:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:04:02 2017 begin with 300116890 relations and 184061807 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:05:03 2017 reduce to 300058643 relations and 181087422 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:05:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:05:56 2017 removing 4857231 relations and 2857231 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:06:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:06:07 2017 begin with 295201412 relations and 181087422 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:07:08 2017 reduce to 295138557 relations and 178166519 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:07:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:08:02 2017 removing 4849485 relations and 2849485 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:08:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:08:15 2017 begin with 290289072 relations and 178166519 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:09:11 2017 reduce to 290224620 relations and 175251724 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:09:11 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:10:04 2017 removing 4894816 relations and 2894816 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:10:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:10:14 2017 begin with 285329804 relations and 175251724 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:11:11 2017 reduce to 285265420 relations and 172291640 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:11:11 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:12:05 2017 removing 4888209 relations and 2888209 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:12:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:12:16 2017 begin with 280377211 relations and 172291640 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:13:10 2017 reduce to 280306893 relations and 169332168 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:13:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:14:02 2017 removing 4860529 relations and 2860529 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:14:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:14:12 2017 begin with 275446364 relations and 169332168 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:15:08 2017 reduce to 275373364 relations and 166397672 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:15:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:16:00 2017 removing 4903482 relations and 2903482 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:16:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:16:12 2017 begin with 270469882 relations and 166397672 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:17:03 2017 reduce to 270400452 relations and 163423784 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:17:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:17:57 2017 removing 4921373 relations and 2921373 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:18:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:18:08 2017 begin with 265479079 relations and 163423784 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:19:02 2017 reduce to 265411799 relations and 160434131 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:19:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:19:52 2017 removing 4927277 relations and 2927277 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:19:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:20:04 2017 begin with 260484522 relations and 160434131 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:20:53 2017 reduce to 260412242 relations and 157433503 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:20:53 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Thu Dec 7 20:21:41 2017 removing 4912532 relations and 2912532 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:21:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:21:50 2017 begin with 255499710 relations and 157433503 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:22:44 2017 reduce to 255427782 relations and 154447930 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:22:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Thu Dec 7 20:23:33 2017 removing 4898377 relations and 2898377 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:23:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:23:42 2017 begin with 250529405 relations and 154447930 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:24:29 2017 reduce to 250448738 relations and 151467639 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:24:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Thu Dec 7 20:25:17 2017 removing 4907864 relations and 2907864 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:25:20 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:25:25 2017 begin with 245540874 relations and 151467639 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:26:19 2017 reduce to 245458845 relations and 148476533 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:26:19 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Thu Dec 7 20:27:09 2017 removing 4930983 relations and 2930983 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:27:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:27:18 2017 begin with 240527862 relations and 148476533 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:28:00 2017 reduce to 240449491 relations and 145465913 ideals in 5 passes Thu Dec 7 20:28:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Thu Dec 7 20:28:46 2017 removing 4939180 relations and 2939180 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:28:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:28:55 2017 begin with 235510311 relations and 145465913 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:29:51 2017 reduce to 235430103 relations and 142445206 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:29:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:30:38 2017 removing 4927835 relations and 2927835 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:30:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:30:47 2017 begin with 230502268 relations and 142445206 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:31:30 2017 reduce to 230411923 relations and 139425520 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:31:30 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:32:12 2017 removing 4951007 relations and 2951007 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:32:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:32:20 2017 begin with 225460916 relations and 139425520 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:33:00 2017 reduce to 225373989 relations and 136386111 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:33:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:33:40 2017 removing 4922993 relations and 2922993 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:33:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:33:49 2017 begin with 220450996 relations and 136386111 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:34:29 2017 reduce to 220357642 relations and 133368132 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:34:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:35:12 2017 removing 4925769 relations and 2925769 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:35:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:35:19 2017 begin with 215431873 relations and 133368132 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:36:06 2017 reduce to 215334442 relations and 130343256 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:36:06 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:36:45 2017 removing 4923795 relations and 2923795 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:36:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:36:52 2017 begin with 210410647 relations and 130343256 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:37:32 2017 reduce to 210310639 relations and 127317681 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:37:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:38:13 2017 removing 4927883 relations and 2927883 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:38:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:38:21 2017 begin with 205382756 relations and 127317681 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:39:02 2017 reduce to 205280359 relations and 124285751 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:39:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:39:41 2017 removing 4940924 relations and 2940924 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:39:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:39:49 2017 begin with 200339435 relations and 124285751 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:40:24 2017 reduce to 200233898 relations and 121237483 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:40:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:41:03 2017 removing 5009245 relations and 3009245 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:41:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:41:10 2017 begin with 195224653 relations and 121237483 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:41:45 2017 reduce to 195119353 relations and 118121175 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:41:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:42:21 2017 removing 5025346 relations and 3025346 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:42:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:42:28 2017 begin with 190094007 relations and 118121175 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:43:01 2017 reduce to 189992997 relations and 114993158 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:43:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:43:38 2017 removing 5039614 relations and 3039614 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:43:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:43:45 2017 begin with 184953383 relations and 114993158 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:44:18 2017 reduce to 184845868 relations and 111844206 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:44:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:44:55 2017 removing 5012811 relations and 3012811 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:44:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:45:01 2017 begin with 179833057 relations and 111844206 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:45:32 2017 reduce to 179717060 relations and 108713485 ideals in 6 passes Thu Dec 7 20:45:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:46:06 2017 removing 5041586 relations and 3041586 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:46:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:46:12 2017 begin with 174675474 relations and 108713485 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:46:48 2017 reduce to 174558454 relations and 105552894 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:46:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Thu Dec 7 20:47:21 2017 removing 5061438 relations and 3061438 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:47:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:47:28 2017 begin with 169497016 relations and 105552894 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:48:00 2017 reduce to 169369281 relations and 102361550 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:48:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 20:48:33 2017 removing 5064285 relations and 3064285 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:48:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:48:39 2017 begin with 164304996 relations and 102361550 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:49:12 2017 reduce to 164167491 relations and 99157477 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:49:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 20:49:43 2017 removing 5098737 relations and 3098737 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:49:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:49:49 2017 begin with 159068754 relations and 99157477 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:50:22 2017 reduce to 158931007 relations and 95918675 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:50:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Thu Dec 7 20:50:52 2017 removing 5150506 relations and 3150506 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:50:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:50:58 2017 begin with 153780501 relations and 95918675 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:51:29 2017 reduce to 153642330 relations and 92627734 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:51:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 20:51:58 2017 removing 5164838 relations and 3164838 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:52:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:52:04 2017 begin with 148477492 relations and 92627734 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:52:31 2017 reduce to 148330906 relations and 89313867 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:52:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 20:53:00 2017 removing 5195788 relations and 3195788 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:53:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:53:05 2017 begin with 143135118 relations and 89313867 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:53:32 2017 reduce to 142987643 relations and 85968211 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:53:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 20:54:00 2017 removing 5206267 relations and 3206267 ideals in 2000000 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:54:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:54:06 2017 begin with 137781376 relations and 85968211 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:54:36 2017 reduce to 137636120 relations and 82614490 ideals in 8 passes Thu Dec 7 20:54:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Thu Dec 7 20:55:02 2017 removing 4364787 relations and 2696201 ideals in 1668586 cliques Thu Dec 7 20:55:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Thu Dec 7 20:55:08 2017 begin with 133271333 relations and 82614490 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:55:31 2017 reduce to 133149029 relations and 79794267 ideals in 7 passes Thu Dec 7 20:55:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 0 large ideals: 11721902 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 1 large ideals: 42607075 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 2 large ideals: 51932852 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 3 large ideals: 22192480 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 4 large ideals: 4099752 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 5 large ideals: 539561 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 6 large ideals: 52199 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 relations with 7+ large ideals: 3208 Thu Dec 7 20:56:01 2017 commencing 2-way merge Thu Dec 7 20:56:36 2017 reduce to 90144938 relation sets and 36790176 unique ideals Thu Dec 7 20:56:36 2017 commencing full merge Thu Dec 7 21:01:06 2017 memory use: 3719.9 MB Thu Dec 7 21:01:14 2017 found 53180865 cycles, need 45994203 Thu Dec 7 21:01:26 2017 weight of 45994203 cycles is about 3154110886 (68.58/cycle) Thu Dec 7 21:01:27 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Thu Dec 7 21:01:27 2017 1 relations: 11721902 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 2 relations: 5419912 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 3 relations: 4433199 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 4 relations: 4121440 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 5 relations: 3918367 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 6 relations: 3576641 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 7 relations: 3228309 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 8 relations: 2810145 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 9 relations: 2366832 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 10+ relations: 4397456 Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 heaviest cycle: 14 relations Thu Dec 7 21:01:28 2017 commencing cycle optimization Thu Dec 7 21:02:16 2017 start with 207214989 relations Thu Dec 7 21:05:31 2017 pruned 16161648 relations Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 memory use: 6522.6 MB Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 1 relations: 11721902 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 2 relations: 5689274 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 3 relations: 4851744 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 4 relations: 4644187 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 5 relations: 4531296 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 6 relations: 4100970 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 7 relations: 3551964 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 8 relations: 2768269 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 9 relations: 1979654 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 10+ relations: 2154943 Thu Dec 7 21:05:32 2017 heaviest cycle: 14 relations Thu Dec 7 21:06:23 2017 RelProcTime: 78836 Thu Dec 7 21:06:40 2017 elapsed time 21:54:14 Sun Dec 10 14:14:51 2017 Sun Dec 10 14:14:51 2017 Sun Dec 10 14:14:51 2017 Msieve v. 1.53 (SVN 993) Sun Dec 10 14:14:51 2017 random seeds: 2d980310 6d12cb4b Sun Dec 10 14:14:51 2017 factoring 18990123508557902868419834986612849212629329047848408031918356871905091180915018818857084783656883790655928770567349115604303665109625610225945717466120031386943078873289069222693826896799892056101 (197 digits) Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 commencing number field sieve (197-digit input) Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 R0: 119738888098469732352733201 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 R1: -6705343098319824504035000000000000000000000000 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A0: 710432 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A1: 0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A2: 0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A3: 0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A4: 0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A5: 0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 A6: 35 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 skew 5.22, size 2.773e-14, alpha -0.778, combined = 8.262e-15 rroots = 0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 commencing relation filtering Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 setting target matrix density to 200.0 Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 estimated available RAM is 32087.4 MB Sun Dec 10 14:14:53 2017 commencing duplicate removal, pass 1 Sun Dec 10 14:24:17 2017 error -1 reading relation 70029288 Sun Dec 10 14:27:38 2017 error -1 reading relation 95039138 Sun Dec 10 14:30:30 2017 error -1 reading relation 116435239 Sun Dec 10 14:43:23 2017 error -1 reading relation 212615363 Sun Dec 10 14:45:00 2017 error -1 reading relation 224828971 Sun Dec 10 14:45:36 2017 error -1 reading relation 229271190 Sun Dec 10 14:48:10 2017 error -11 reading relation 248233103 Sun Dec 10 14:49:03 2017 error -11 reading relation 254922840 Sun Dec 10 15:14:51 2017 error -1 reading relation 447758390 Sun Dec 10 15:16:28 2017 error -1 reading relation 459947758 Sun Dec 10 15:21:53 2017 error -6 reading relation 500177949 Sun Dec 10 15:32:12 2017 error -1 reading relation 577516583 Sun Dec 10 15:32:48 2017 error -1 reading relation 581956099 Sun Dec 10 15:35:33 2017 error -11 reading relation 602411634 Sun Dec 10 15:46:18 2017 error -1 reading relation 682892702 Sun Dec 10 16:01:29 2017 skipped 4035 relations with b > 2^32 Sun Dec 10 16:01:29 2017 found 117038956 hash collisions in 796421275 relations Sun Dec 10 16:01:40 2017 added 1624 free relations Sun Dec 10 16:01:40 2017 commencing duplicate removal, pass 2 Sun Dec 10 16:09:14 2017 found 1 duplicates and 796422898 unique relations Sun Dec 10 16:09:14 2017 memory use: 4518.0 MB Sun Dec 10 16:09:14 2017 reading ideals above 545587200 Sun Dec 10 16:09:14 2017 commencing singleton removal, initial pass Sun Dec 10 17:28:35 2017 memory use: 11024.0 MB Sun Dec 10 17:28:35 2017 reading all ideals from disk Sun Dec 10 17:29:02 2017 memory use: 14603.0 MB Sun Dec 10 17:30:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 17:31:11 2017 begin with 796422898 relations and 529369930 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 17:39:06 2017 reduce to 685376474 relations and 414271329 ideals in 11 passes Sun Dec 10 17:39:06 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 49 Sun Dec 10 17:39:55 2017 reading ideals above 720000 Sun Dec 10 17:39:55 2017 commencing singleton removal, initial pass Sun Dec 10 19:14:58 2017 memory use: 11024.0 MB Sun Dec 10 19:14:59 2017 reading large ideals from disk Sun Dec 10 19:20:47 2017 keeping 415649060 ideals with weight <= 20, target excess is 55856811 Sun Dec 10 19:32:45 2017 memory use: 14304.3 MB Sun Dec 10 19:32:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 19:33:05 2017 begin with 685376474 relations and 415649060 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 19:34:36 2017 reduce to 685376379 relations and 415648965 ideals in 4 passes Sun Dec 10 19:34:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 19:36:54 2017 removing 10170723 relations and 8170723 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 19:37:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 19:37:20 2017 begin with 675205656 relations and 415648965 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 19:39:34 2017 reduce to 675070055 relations and 407342039 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 19:39:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 19:41:47 2017 removing 7830173 relations and 5830173 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 19:41:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 19:42:13 2017 begin with 667239882 relations and 407342039 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 19:44:26 2017 reduce to 667146046 relations and 401417666 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 19:44:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 19:46:36 2017 removing 7091813 relations and 5091813 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 19:46:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 19:47:01 2017 begin with 660054233 relations and 401417666 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 19:49:10 2017 reduce to 659973054 relations and 396244374 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 19:49:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 19:51:17 2017 removing 6708085 relations and 4708085 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 19:51:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 19:51:41 2017 begin with 653264969 relations and 396244374 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 19:53:47 2017 reduce to 653191876 relations and 391462975 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 19:53:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 19:55:52 2017 removing 6428594 relations and 4428594 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 19:56:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 19:56:16 2017 begin with 646763282 relations and 391462975 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 19:58:21 2017 reduce to 646695067 relations and 386965923 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 19:58:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:00:26 2017 removing 6261746 relations and 4261746 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:00:34 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:00:50 2017 begin with 640433321 relations and 386965923 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:02:53 2017 reduce to 640369145 relations and 382639767 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:02:53 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:04:57 2017 removing 6134714 relations and 4134714 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:05:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:05:20 2017 begin with 634234431 relations and 382639767 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:07:43 2017 reduce to 634175892 relations and 378446298 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 20:07:43 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:09:45 2017 removing 5949259 relations and 3949259 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:09:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:10:08 2017 begin with 628226633 relations and 378446298 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:11:48 2017 reduce to 628166340 relations and 374436508 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 20:11:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:13:49 2017 removing 5945778 relations and 3945778 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:13:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:14:12 2017 begin with 622220562 relations and 374436508 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:15:50 2017 reduce to 622166216 relations and 370436166 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 20:15:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:17:50 2017 removing 5800964 relations and 3800964 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:17:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:18:12 2017 begin with 616365252 relations and 370436166 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:19:49 2017 reduce to 616309193 relations and 366578934 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 20:19:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:21:48 2017 removing 5687290 relations and 3687290 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:21:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:22:11 2017 begin with 610621903 relations and 366578934 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:24:06 2017 reduce to 610567087 relations and 362836586 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:24:06 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:26:04 2017 removing 5698666 relations and 3698666 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:26:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:26:26 2017 begin with 604868421 relations and 362836586 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:28:01 2017 reduce to 604816128 relations and 359085371 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 20:28:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:29:58 2017 removing 5678228 relations and 3678228 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:30:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:30:20 2017 begin with 599137900 relations and 359085371 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:32:12 2017 reduce to 599086400 relations and 355355382 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:32:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:34:08 2017 removing 5545031 relations and 3545031 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:34:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:34:30 2017 begin with 593541369 relations and 355355382 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:36:21 2017 reduce to 593489268 relations and 351758025 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:36:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:38:16 2017 removing 5571176 relations and 3571176 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:38:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:38:37 2017 begin with 587918092 relations and 351758025 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:40:28 2017 reduce to 587869960 relations and 348138437 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:40:28 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:42:22 2017 removing 5464804 relations and 3464804 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:42:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:42:43 2017 begin with 582405156 relations and 348138437 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:44:32 2017 reduce to 582354261 relations and 344622480 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:44:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:46:25 2017 removing 5468325 relations and 3468325 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:46:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:46:46 2017 begin with 576885936 relations and 344622480 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:48:33 2017 reduce to 576833684 relations and 341101615 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:48:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:50:25 2017 removing 5423617 relations and 3423617 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:50:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:50:46 2017 begin with 571410067 relations and 341101615 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:52:32 2017 reduce to 571359801 relations and 337627458 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:52:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:54:22 2017 removing 5453588 relations and 3453588 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:54:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:54:43 2017 begin with 565906213 relations and 337627458 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 20:56:27 2017 reduce to 565858751 relations and 334126165 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 20:56:27 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 20:58:17 2017 removing 5320290 relations and 3320290 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 20:58:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 20:58:37 2017 begin with 560538461 relations and 334126165 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:00:38 2017 reduce to 560490101 relations and 330757186 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 21:00:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:02:27 2017 removing 5420739 relations and 3420739 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:02:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:02:47 2017 begin with 555069362 relations and 330757186 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:04:29 2017 reduce to 555024457 relations and 327291272 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:04:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:06:15 2017 removing 5351367 relations and 3351367 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:06:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:06:35 2017 begin with 549673090 relations and 327291272 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:08:00 2017 reduce to 549626809 relations and 323893312 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 21:08:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:09:46 2017 removing 5212752 relations and 3212752 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:09:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:10:06 2017 begin with 544414057 relations and 323893312 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:11:47 2017 reduce to 544357141 relations and 320623293 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:11:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:13:31 2017 removing 5271906 relations and 3271906 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:13:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:13:51 2017 begin with 539085235 relations and 320623293 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:15:13 2017 reduce to 539033287 relations and 317299092 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 21:15:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:16:57 2017 removing 5234482 relations and 3234482 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:17:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:17:16 2017 begin with 533798805 relations and 317299092 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:18:55 2017 reduce to 533748519 relations and 314013929 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:18:55 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:20:38 2017 removing 5253408 relations and 3253408 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:20:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:20:57 2017 begin with 528495111 relations and 314013929 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:22:34 2017 reduce to 528445666 relations and 310710687 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:22:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:24:14 2017 removing 5276985 relations and 3276985 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:24:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:24:33 2017 begin with 523168681 relations and 310710687 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:26:09 2017 reduce to 523122668 relations and 307387314 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:26:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:27:48 2017 removing 5215560 relations and 3215560 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:27:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:28:07 2017 begin with 517907108 relations and 307387314 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:29:26 2017 reduce to 517860854 relations and 304125165 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 21:29:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:31:05 2017 removing 5181810 relations and 3181810 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:31:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:31:23 2017 begin with 512679044 relations and 304125165 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:32:56 2017 reduce to 512631437 relations and 300895358 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:32:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:34:32 2017 removing 5219603 relations and 3219603 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:34:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:34:50 2017 begin with 507411834 relations and 300895358 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:36:07 2017 reduce to 507364281 relations and 297627797 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 21:36:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:37:42 2017 removing 5168202 relations and 3168202 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:37:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:38:00 2017 begin with 502196079 relations and 297627797 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:39:31 2017 reduce to 502150378 relations and 294413522 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:39:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:41:04 2017 removing 5198303 relations and 3198303 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:41:10 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:41:22 2017 begin with 496952075 relations and 294413522 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:42:55 2017 reduce to 496904993 relations and 291167733 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:42:55 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:44:28 2017 removing 4931416 relations and 2931416 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:44:34 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:44:45 2017 begin with 491973577 relations and 291167733 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:46:17 2017 reduce to 491910441 relations and 288172662 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:46:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:47:46 2017 removing 5149317 relations and 3149317 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:47:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:48:03 2017 begin with 486761124 relations and 288172662 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:49:17 2017 reduce to 486708379 relations and 284970070 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 21:49:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:50:48 2017 removing 5146046 relations and 3146046 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:50:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:51:05 2017 begin with 481562333 relations and 284970070 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:52:33 2017 reduce to 481514755 relations and 281776006 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:52:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:54:01 2017 removing 5099405 relations and 3099405 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:54:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:54:18 2017 begin with 476415350 relations and 281776006 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:55:29 2017 reduce to 476368706 relations and 278629534 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 21:55:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 21:56:57 2017 removing 5099531 relations and 3099531 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 21:57:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 21:57:14 2017 begin with 471269175 relations and 278629534 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 21:58:38 2017 reduce to 471220963 relations and 275481306 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 21:58:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:00:05 2017 removing 5128131 relations and 3128131 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:00:10 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:00:21 2017 begin with 466092832 relations and 275481306 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:01:31 2017 reduce to 466045704 relations and 272305604 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 22:01:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:02:56 2017 removing 5094208 relations and 3094208 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:03:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:03:13 2017 begin with 460951496 relations and 272305604 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:04:22 2017 reduce to 460905336 relations and 269164809 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 22:04:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:05:44 2017 removing 5099962 relations and 3099962 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:05:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:06:00 2017 begin with 455805374 relations and 269164809 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:07:22 2017 reduce to 455757616 relations and 266016617 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:07:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:08:41 2017 removing 4926876 relations and 2926876 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:08:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:08:57 2017 begin with 450830740 relations and 266016617 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:10:17 2017 reduce to 450772940 relations and 263031423 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:10:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:11:35 2017 removing 5064414 relations and 3064414 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:11:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:11:51 2017 begin with 445708526 relations and 263031423 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:13:23 2017 reduce to 445660097 relations and 259918094 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 22:13:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:14:40 2017 removing 5079582 relations and 3079582 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:14:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:14:55 2017 begin with 440580515 relations and 259918094 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:16:14 2017 reduce to 440529542 relations and 256786983 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:16:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:17:31 2017 removing 5050044 relations and 3050044 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:17:36 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:17:46 2017 begin with 435479498 relations and 256786983 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:19:03 2017 reduce to 435430818 relations and 253687768 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:19:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:20:19 2017 removing 5035574 relations and 3035574 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:20:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:20:34 2017 begin with 430395244 relations and 253687768 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:21:50 2017 reduce to 430346564 relations and 250602929 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:21:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:23:05 2017 removing 5054485 relations and 3054485 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:23:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:23:20 2017 begin with 425292079 relations and 250602929 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:24:35 2017 reduce to 425241830 relations and 247497679 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:24:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:25:50 2017 removing 4891687 relations and 2891687 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:25:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:26:04 2017 begin with 420350143 relations and 247497679 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:27:19 2017 reduce to 420291452 relations and 244546638 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:27:19 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:28:32 2017 removing 4959613 relations and 2959613 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:28:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:28:48 2017 begin with 415331839 relations and 244546638 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:30:03 2017 reduce to 415273529 relations and 241528086 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:30:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:31:17 2017 removing 4989150 relations and 2989150 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:31:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:31:31 2017 begin with 410284379 relations and 241528086 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:32:44 2017 reduce to 410233173 relations and 238487168 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:32:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:33:57 2017 removing 5035881 relations and 3035881 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:34:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:34:11 2017 begin with 405197292 relations and 238487168 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:35:22 2017 reduce to 405147975 relations and 235401420 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:35:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:36:34 2017 removing 5032026 relations and 3032026 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:36:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:36:48 2017 begin with 400115949 relations and 235401420 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:37:47 2017 reduce to 400070120 relations and 232323043 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 22:37:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:38:58 2017 removing 4921871 relations and 2921871 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:39:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:39:11 2017 begin with 395148249 relations and 232323043 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:40:20 2017 reduce to 395089366 relations and 229341685 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:40:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:41:30 2017 removing 5027423 relations and 3027423 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:41:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:41:44 2017 begin with 390061943 relations and 229341685 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:42:52 2017 reduce to 390012743 relations and 226264558 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:42:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:44:01 2017 removing 5014177 relations and 3014177 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:44:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:44:14 2017 begin with 384998566 relations and 226264558 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:45:10 2017 reduce to 384950742 relations and 223201996 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 22:45:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:46:18 2017 removing 4921535 relations and 2921535 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:46:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:46:31 2017 begin with 380029207 relations and 223201996 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:47:37 2017 reduce to 379968210 relations and 220218797 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:47:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:48:44 2017 removing 4987810 relations and 2987810 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:48:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:48:57 2017 begin with 374980400 relations and 220218797 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:50:02 2017 reduce to 374930456 relations and 217180478 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:50:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:51:08 2017 removing 4914873 relations and 2914873 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:51:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:51:21 2017 begin with 370015583 relations and 217180478 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:52:25 2017 reduce to 369961959 relations and 214211310 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:52:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:53:30 2017 removing 4854356 relations and 2854356 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:53:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:53:43 2017 begin with 365107603 relations and 214211310 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:54:35 2017 reduce to 365049851 relations and 211298501 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 22:54:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:55:40 2017 removing 4927358 relations and 2927358 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:55:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:55:53 2017 begin with 360122493 relations and 211298501 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:56:56 2017 reduce to 360056331 relations and 208304263 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:56:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 22:58:00 2017 removing 4950919 relations and 2950919 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 22:58:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 22:58:12 2017 begin with 355105412 relations and 208304263 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 22:59:13 2017 reduce to 355050391 relations and 205297662 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 22:59:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:00:16 2017 removing 4979662 relations and 2979662 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:00:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:00:29 2017 begin with 350070729 relations and 205297662 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:01:32 2017 reduce to 350016170 relations and 202262720 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:01:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:02:35 2017 removing 4915056 relations and 2915056 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:02:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:02:46 2017 begin with 345101114 relations and 202262720 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:03:46 2017 reduce to 345035612 relations and 199281432 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:03:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:04:48 2017 removing 4969740 relations and 2969740 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:04:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:05:00 2017 begin with 340065872 relations and 199281432 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:05:57 2017 reduce to 340011699 relations and 196256798 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:05:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:06:59 2017 removing 4932573 relations and 2932573 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:07:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:07:10 2017 begin with 335079126 relations and 196256798 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:07:59 2017 reduce to 335013579 relations and 193257820 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 23:07:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:08:56 2017 removing 4912982 relations and 2912982 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:09:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:09:07 2017 begin with 330100597 relations and 193257820 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:10:03 2017 reduce to 330038747 relations and 190282163 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:10:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:10:58 2017 removing 4863783 relations and 2863783 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:11:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:11:09 2017 begin with 325174964 relations and 190282163 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:12:04 2017 reduce to 325107478 relations and 187349923 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:12:04 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:12:59 2017 removing 4890353 relations and 2890353 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:13:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:13:10 2017 begin with 320217125 relations and 187349923 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:14:03 2017 reduce to 320150704 relations and 184392197 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:14:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:14:57 2017 removing 4953577 relations and 2953577 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:15:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:15:08 2017 begin with 315197127 relations and 184392197 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:16:01 2017 reduce to 315137392 relations and 181378061 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:16:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:16:54 2017 removing 4961618 relations and 2961618 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:16:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:17:05 2017 begin with 310175774 relations and 181378061 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:17:57 2017 reduce to 310116611 relations and 178356490 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:17:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:18:49 2017 removing 4924073 relations and 2924073 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:18:53 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:18:59 2017 begin with 305192538 relations and 178356490 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:19:50 2017 reduce to 305133045 relations and 175372147 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:19:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:20:41 2017 removing 4899923 relations and 2899923 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:20:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:20:51 2017 begin with 300233122 relations and 175372147 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:21:41 2017 reduce to 300170176 relations and 172408389 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:21:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:22:32 2017 removing 4893157 relations and 2893157 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:22:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:22:41 2017 begin with 295277019 relations and 172408389 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:23:22 2017 reduce to 295208677 relations and 169445891 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 23:23:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:24:12 2017 removing 4993162 relations and 2993162 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:24:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:24:22 2017 begin with 290215515 relations and 169445891 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:25:02 2017 reduce to 290156594 relations and 166393020 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 23:25:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:25:51 2017 removing 4930445 relations and 2930445 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:25:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:26:00 2017 begin with 285226149 relations and 166393020 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:26:47 2017 reduce to 285163477 relations and 163399042 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:26:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:27:36 2017 removing 4931137 relations and 2931137 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:27:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:27:45 2017 begin with 280232340 relations and 163399042 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:28:39 2017 reduce to 280169274 relations and 160404008 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:28:39 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:29:26 2017 removing 4922639 relations and 2922639 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:29:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:29:35 2017 begin with 275246635 relations and 160404008 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:30:27 2017 reduce to 275182468 relations and 157416384 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:30:27 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:31:13 2017 removing 4898462 relations and 2898462 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:31:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:31:22 2017 begin with 270284006 relations and 157416384 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:31:59 2017 reduce to 270224749 relations and 154457915 ideals in 5 passes Sun Dec 10 23:31:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:32:45 2017 removing 4891690 relations and 2891690 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:32:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:32:53 2017 begin with 265333059 relations and 154457915 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:33:37 2017 reduce to 265269075 relations and 151501403 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:33:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:34:22 2017 removing 4953800 relations and 2953800 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:34:25 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:34:30 2017 begin with 260315275 relations and 151501403 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:35:13 2017 reduce to 260252192 relations and 148483791 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:35:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:35:57 2017 removing 4969065 relations and 2969065 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:36:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:36:06 2017 begin with 255283127 relations and 148483791 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:36:47 2017 reduce to 255222825 relations and 145453768 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:36:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Sun Dec 10 23:37:29 2017 removing 4937724 relations and 2937724 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:37:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:37:38 2017 begin with 250285101 relations and 145453768 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:38:18 2017 reduce to 250219532 relations and 142449749 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:38:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Sun Dec 10 23:39:00 2017 removing 4951222 relations and 2951222 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:39:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:39:08 2017 begin with 245268310 relations and 142449749 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:39:53 2017 reduce to 245203202 relations and 139432670 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:39:53 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:40:34 2017 removing 4930897 relations and 2930897 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:40:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:40:42 2017 begin with 240272305 relations and 139432670 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:41:20 2017 reduce to 240180300 relations and 136408736 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:41:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:42:01 2017 removing 4882212 relations and 2882212 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:42:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:42:09 2017 begin with 235298088 relations and 136408736 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:42:52 2017 reduce to 235200239 relations and 133427514 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:42:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:43:32 2017 removing 4861418 relations and 2861418 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:43:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:43:39 2017 begin with 230338821 relations and 133427514 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:44:22 2017 reduce to 230234323 relations and 130460329 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:44:22 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:45:01 2017 removing 4850122 relations and 2850122 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:45:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:45:09 2017 begin with 225384201 relations and 130460329 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:45:50 2017 reduce to 225272480 relations and 127496921 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:45:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:46:29 2017 removing 4830092 relations and 2830092 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:46:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:46:36 2017 begin with 220442388 relations and 127496921 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:47:10 2017 reduce to 220323176 relations and 124545701 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:47:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:47:49 2017 removing 4807589 relations and 2807589 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:47:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:47:56 2017 begin with 215515587 relations and 124545701 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:48:35 2017 reduce to 215384664 relations and 121604758 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:48:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:49:13 2017 removing 4869937 relations and 2869937 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:49:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:49:19 2017 begin with 210514727 relations and 121604758 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:49:52 2017 reduce to 210393791 relations and 118611341 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:49:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:50:29 2017 removing 4937460 relations and 2937460 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:50:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:50:36 2017 begin with 205456331 relations and 118611341 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:51:07 2017 reduce to 205324740 relations and 115539308 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:51:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:51:43 2017 removing 4960998 relations and 2960998 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:51:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:51:50 2017 begin with 200363742 relations and 115539308 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:52:25 2017 reduce to 200261358 relations and 112473538 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:52:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Sun Dec 10 23:53:01 2017 removing 5014995 relations and 3014995 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:53:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:53:07 2017 begin with 195246363 relations and 112473538 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:53:37 2017 reduce to 195116616 relations and 109325742 ideals in 6 passes Sun Dec 10 23:53:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Sun Dec 10 23:54:11 2017 removing 4997283 relations and 2997283 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:54:14 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:54:18 2017 begin with 190119333 relations and 109325742 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:54:51 2017 reduce to 189997308 relations and 106203659 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:54:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Sun Dec 10 23:55:25 2017 removing 5026103 relations and 3026103 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:55:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:55:31 2017 begin with 184971205 relations and 106203659 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:56:03 2017 reduce to 184844532 relations and 103048000 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:56:03 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Sun Dec 10 23:56:36 2017 removing 5038377 relations and 3038377 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:56:38 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:56:41 2017 begin with 179806155 relations and 103048000 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:57:12 2017 reduce to 179695302 relations and 99896295 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:57:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Sun Dec 10 23:57:44 2017 removing 5109610 relations and 3109610 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:57:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:57:50 2017 begin with 174585692 relations and 99896295 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:58:20 2017 reduce to 174472417 relations and 96670941 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:58:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Sun Dec 10 23:58:51 2017 removing 5058881 relations and 3058881 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:58:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Sun Dec 10 23:58:57 2017 begin with 169413536 relations and 96670941 unique ideals Sun Dec 10 23:59:26 2017 reduce to 169269297 relations and 93464832 ideals in 7 passes Sun Dec 10 23:59:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Sun Dec 10 23:59:56 2017 removing 4933633 relations and 2933633 ideals in 2000000 cliques Sun Dec 10 23:59:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:00:01 2017 begin with 164335664 relations and 93464832 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:00:29 2017 reduce to 164172956 relations and 90365355 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 00:00:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Mon Dec 11 00:00:58 2017 removing 4914857 relations and 2914857 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:01:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:01:04 2017 begin with 159258099 relations and 90365355 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:01:34 2017 reduce to 159085213 relations and 87274069 ideals in 8 passes Mon Dec 11 00:01:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Mon Dec 11 00:02:03 2017 removing 5045183 relations and 3045183 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:02:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:02:08 2017 begin with 154040030 relations and 87274069 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:02:34 2017 reduce to 153860672 relations and 84045709 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 00:02:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 16 Mon Dec 11 00:03:02 2017 removing 4977599 relations and 2977599 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:03:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:03:07 2017 begin with 148883073 relations and 84045709 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:03:28 2017 reduce to 148697301 relations and 80878368 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:03:28 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Mon Dec 11 00:03:55 2017 removing 5024955 relations and 3024955 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:03:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:04:00 2017 begin with 143672346 relations and 80878368 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:04:27 2017 reduce to 143515722 relations and 77693597 ideals in 8 passes Mon Dec 11 00:04:27 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Mon Dec 11 00:04:54 2017 removing 2548310 relations and 1520086 ideals in 1028224 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:04:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:04:58 2017 begin with 140967412 relations and 77693597 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:05:27 2017 reduce to 140896307 relations and 76101396 ideals in 8 passes Mon Dec 11 00:05:27 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 15 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 0 large ideals: 18279449 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 1 large ideals: 56242822 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 2 large ideals: 50910171 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 3 large ideals: 13871479 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 4 large ideals: 1454410 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 5 large ideals: 130326 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 6 large ideals: 7429 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 relations with 7+ large ideals: 221 Mon Dec 11 00:05:56 2017 commencing 2-way merge Mon Dec 11 00:06:30 2017 reduce to 93175810 relation sets and 28380899 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:06:30 2017 commencing full merge Mon Dec 11 00:09:00 2017 memory use: 3213.4 MB Mon Dec 11 00:09:07 2017 found 64794223 cycles, need 55857011 Mon Dec 11 00:09:21 2017 weight of 55857011 cycles is about 2432394158 (43.55/cycle) Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 1 relations: 18279449 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 2 relations: 9563412 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 3 relations: 8402009 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 4 relations: 7379441 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 5 relations: 6041040 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 6 relations: 4400051 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 7 relations: 1791010 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 8 relations: 599 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 9 relations: 0 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 10+ relations: 0 Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 heaviest cycle: 8 relations Mon Dec 11 00:09:23 2017 matrix not dense enough, retrying Mon Dec 11 00:09:31 2017 reading large ideals from disk Mon Dec 11 00:15:01 2017 keeping 429125661 ideals with weight <= 25, target excess is 42380210 Mon Dec 11 00:20:53 2017 memory use: 19306.7 MB Mon Dec 11 00:20:53 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:21:14 2017 begin with 685376474 relations and 429125661 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:22:50 2017 reduce to 685376379 relations and 429125566 ideals in 4 passes Mon Dec 11 00:22:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:25:12 2017 removing 10376578 relations and 8376578 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:25:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:25:41 2017 begin with 674999801 relations and 429125566 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:28:09 2017 reduce to 674868645 relations and 420617275 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:28:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:30:29 2017 removing 7999534 relations and 5999534 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:30:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:30:57 2017 begin with 666869111 relations and 420617275 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:33:41 2017 reduce to 666777966 relations and 414526269 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 00:33:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:35:59 2017 removing 7248386 relations and 5248386 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:36:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:36:26 2017 begin with 659529580 relations and 414526269 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:38:47 2017 reduce to 659450892 relations and 409198921 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:38:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:41:03 2017 removing 6810553 relations and 4810553 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:41:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:41:30 2017 begin with 652640339 relations and 409198921 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:43:51 2017 reduce to 652568761 relations and 404316533 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:43:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:46:05 2017 removing 6547468 relations and 4547468 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:46:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:46:32 2017 begin with 646021293 relations and 404316533 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:48:48 2017 reduce to 645955404 relations and 399702935 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:48:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:51:02 2017 removing 6331578 relations and 4331578 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:51:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:51:28 2017 begin with 639623826 relations and 399702935 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:53:42 2017 reduce to 639561062 relations and 395308356 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:53:42 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 00:55:54 2017 removing 6193400 relations and 4193400 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 00:56:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 00:56:20 2017 begin with 633367662 relations and 395308356 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 00:58:37 2017 reduce to 633308250 relations and 391055324 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 00:58:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:00:47 2017 removing 6038518 relations and 4038518 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:00:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:01:13 2017 begin with 627269732 relations and 391055324 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:03:06 2017 reduce to 627211599 relations and 386958449 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 01:03:06 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:05:14 2017 removing 5983810 relations and 3983810 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:05:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:05:39 2017 begin with 621227789 relations and 386958449 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:07:49 2017 reduce to 621173085 relations and 382919733 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:07:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:09:57 2017 removing 5867176 relations and 3867176 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:10:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:10:22 2017 begin with 615305909 relations and 382919733 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:12:09 2017 reduce to 615251897 relations and 378998312 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 01:12:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:14:17 2017 removing 5799095 relations and 3799095 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:14:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:14:42 2017 begin with 609452802 relations and 378998312 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:16:49 2017 reduce to 609399922 relations and 375146113 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:16:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:18:53 2017 removing 5738946 relations and 3738946 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:19:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:19:18 2017 begin with 603660976 relations and 375146113 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:22:08 2017 reduce to 603609829 relations and 371355790 ideals in 8 passes Mon Dec 11 01:22:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:24:14 2017 removing 5698937 relations and 3698937 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:24:22 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:24:40 2017 begin with 597910892 relations and 371355790 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:26:24 2017 reduce to 597860633 relations and 367606362 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 01:26:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:28:29 2017 removing 5602921 relations and 3602921 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:28:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:28:54 2017 begin with 592257712 relations and 367606362 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:30:57 2017 reduce to 592205623 relations and 363951115 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:30:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:33:01 2017 removing 5617853 relations and 3617853 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:33:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:33:25 2017 begin with 586587770 relations and 363951115 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:35:06 2017 reduce to 586539745 relations and 360284972 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 01:35:06 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:37:08 2017 removing 5530666 relations and 3530666 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:37:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:37:31 2017 begin with 581009079 relations and 360284972 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:39:37 2017 reduce to 580959647 relations and 356704602 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:39:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:41:38 2017 removing 5531196 relations and 3531196 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:41:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:42:01 2017 begin with 575428451 relations and 356704602 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:43:59 2017 reduce to 575380234 relations and 353124910 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:43:59 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:45:59 2017 removing 5456819 relations and 3456819 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:46:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:46:22 2017 begin with 569923415 relations and 353124910 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:48:21 2017 reduce to 569873982 relations and 349618360 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:48:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:50:19 2017 removing 5456930 relations and 3456930 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:50:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:50:43 2017 begin with 564417052 relations and 349618360 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:52:43 2017 reduce to 564369350 relations and 346113453 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 01:52:43 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:54:40 2017 removing 5389490 relations and 3389490 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:54:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:55:03 2017 begin with 558979860 relations and 346113453 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 01:57:17 2017 reduce to 558932007 relations and 342675796 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 01:57:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 01:59:13 2017 removing 5413302 relations and 3413302 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 01:59:19 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 01:59:35 2017 begin with 553518705 relations and 342675796 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:01:29 2017 reduce to 553472445 relations and 339215920 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:01:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:03:23 2017 removing 5358971 relations and 3358971 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:03:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:03:46 2017 begin with 548113474 relations and 339215920 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:05:39 2017 reduce to 548065104 relations and 335808274 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:05:39 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:07:34 2017 removing 5332515 relations and 3332515 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:07:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:07:56 2017 begin with 542732589 relations and 335808274 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:09:31 2017 reduce to 542684267 relations and 332427115 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:09:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:11:23 2017 removing 5320827 relations and 3320827 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:11:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:11:45 2017 begin with 537363440 relations and 332427115 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:13:17 2017 reduce to 537315213 relations and 329057712 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:13:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:15:07 2017 removing 5298463 relations and 3298463 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:15:14 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:15:29 2017 begin with 532016750 relations and 329057712 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:17:17 2017 reduce to 531969496 relations and 325711664 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:17:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:19:06 2017 removing 5249966 relations and 3249966 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:19:13 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:19:28 2017 begin with 526719530 relations and 325711664 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:20:57 2017 reduce to 526671149 relations and 322412943 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:20:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:22:44 2017 removing 5280388 relations and 3280388 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:22:50 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:23:06 2017 begin with 521390761 relations and 322412943 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:24:38 2017 reduce to 521344756 relations and 319086204 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:24:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:26:25 2017 removing 5267591 relations and 3267591 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:26:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:26:45 2017 begin with 516077165 relations and 319086204 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:28:13 2017 reduce to 516032069 relations and 315773138 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:28:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:29:58 2017 removing 5236756 relations and 3236756 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:30:04 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:30:19 2017 begin with 510795313 relations and 315773138 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:32:02 2017 reduce to 510749257 relations and 312489991 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:32:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:33:46 2017 removing 5170607 relations and 3170607 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:33:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:34:06 2017 begin with 505578650 relations and 312489991 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:35:33 2017 reduce to 505528598 relations and 309268980 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:35:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:37:13 2017 removing 5199689 relations and 3199689 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:37:19 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:37:33 2017 begin with 500328909 relations and 309268980 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:39:14 2017 reduce to 500280672 relations and 306020684 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:39:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:40:54 2017 removing 5189591 relations and 3189591 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:41:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:41:14 2017 begin with 495091081 relations and 306020684 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:42:37 2017 reduce to 495044028 relations and 302783656 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:42:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:44:20 2017 removing 5140477 relations and 3140477 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:44:26 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:44:39 2017 begin with 489903551 relations and 302783656 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:46:18 2017 reduce to 489854546 relations and 299593743 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:46:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:47:56 2017 removing 5132375 relations and 3132375 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:48:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:48:15 2017 begin with 484722171 relations and 299593743 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:49:37 2017 reduce to 484672780 relations and 296411552 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:49:37 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:51:13 2017 removing 5143562 relations and 3143562 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:51:19 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:51:32 2017 begin with 479529218 relations and 296411552 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:53:08 2017 reduce to 479480413 relations and 293218782 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:53:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:54:41 2017 removing 5159719 relations and 3159719 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:54:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:55:00 2017 begin with 474320694 relations and 293218782 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:56:40 2017 reduce to 474274188 relations and 290012113 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 02:56:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 02:58:14 2017 removing 5121000 relations and 3121000 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 02:58:20 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 02:58:32 2017 begin with 469153188 relations and 290012113 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 02:59:51 2017 reduce to 469105373 relations and 286842855 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 02:59:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:01:24 2017 removing 5100533 relations and 3100533 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:01:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:01:43 2017 begin with 464004840 relations and 286842855 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:03:00 2017 reduce to 463958288 relations and 283695302 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:03:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:04:32 2017 removing 5102043 relations and 3102043 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:04:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:04:50 2017 begin with 458856245 relations and 283695302 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:06:06 2017 reduce to 458808386 relations and 280544949 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:06:06 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:07:37 2017 removing 5114925 relations and 3114925 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:07:43 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:07:55 2017 begin with 453693461 relations and 280544949 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:09:11 2017 reduce to 453646676 relations and 277382798 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:09:11 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:10:40 2017 removing 5072291 relations and 3072291 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:10:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:10:58 2017 begin with 448574385 relations and 277382798 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:12:12 2017 reduce to 448526016 relations and 274261659 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:12:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:13:40 2017 removing 5100865 relations and 3100865 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:13:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:13:58 2017 begin with 443425151 relations and 274261659 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:15:12 2017 reduce to 443377626 relations and 271112800 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:15:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:16:42 2017 removing 5049973 relations and 3049973 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:16:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:17:00 2017 begin with 438327653 relations and 271112800 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:18:19 2017 reduce to 438279545 relations and 268014176 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:18:19 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:19:49 2017 removing 5078492 relations and 3078492 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:19:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:20:07 2017 begin with 433201053 relations and 268014176 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:21:40 2017 reduce to 433152907 relations and 264887036 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 03:21:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:23:04 2017 removing 4954180 relations and 2954180 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:23:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:23:21 2017 begin with 428198727 relations and 264887036 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:24:31 2017 reduce to 428142882 relations and 261876451 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:24:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:25:52 2017 removing 5050003 relations and 3050003 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:25:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:26:09 2017 begin with 423092879 relations and 261876451 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:27:18 2017 reduce to 423041332 relations and 258774329 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:27:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:28:39 2017 removing 5034657 relations and 3034657 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:28:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:28:55 2017 begin with 418006675 relations and 258774329 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:30:17 2017 reduce to 417957220 relations and 255689709 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 03:30:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:31:36 2017 removing 5026472 relations and 3026472 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:31:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:31:52 2017 begin with 412930748 relations and 255689709 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:33:00 2017 reduce to 412881077 relations and 252613036 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:33:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:34:18 2017 removing 5009108 relations and 3009108 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:34:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:34:34 2017 begin with 407871969 relations and 252613036 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:35:41 2017 reduce to 407821071 relations and 249552507 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:35:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:36:58 2017 removing 5021372 relations and 3021372 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:37:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:37:14 2017 begin with 402799699 relations and 249552507 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:38:32 2017 reduce to 402749808 relations and 246480694 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 03:38:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:39:49 2017 removing 4988741 relations and 2988741 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:39:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:40:05 2017 begin with 397761067 relations and 246480694 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:41:09 2017 reduce to 397709537 relations and 243439808 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:41:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:42:25 2017 removing 5023553 relations and 3023553 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:42:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:42:41 2017 begin with 392685984 relations and 243439808 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:43:57 2017 reduce to 392635094 relations and 240364827 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 03:43:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:45:12 2017 removing 4997555 relations and 2997555 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:45:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:45:27 2017 begin with 387637539 relations and 240364827 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:46:30 2017 reduce to 387587828 relations and 237316991 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:46:30 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:47:44 2017 removing 5020126 relations and 3020126 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:47:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:47:59 2017 begin with 382567702 relations and 237316991 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:49:00 2017 reduce to 382517027 relations and 234245600 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:49:00 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 25 Mon Dec 11 03:50:14 2017 removing 4979348 relations and 2979348 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:50:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:50:28 2017 begin with 377537679 relations and 234245600 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:51:29 2017 reduce to 377486862 relations and 231214879 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:51:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 03:52:41 2017 removing 4998351 relations and 2998351 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:52:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:52:56 2017 begin with 372488511 relations and 231214879 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:53:56 2017 reduce to 372438182 relations and 228165617 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 03:53:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 03:55:07 2017 removing 4980003 relations and 2980003 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:55:12 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:55:21 2017 begin with 367458179 relations and 228165617 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:56:44 2017 reduce to 367405313 relations and 225132163 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 03:56:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 03:57:54 2017 removing 4892508 relations and 2892508 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 03:57:59 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 03:58:08 2017 begin with 362512805 relations and 225132163 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 03:59:18 2017 reduce to 362454470 relations and 222180680 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 03:59:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:00:29 2017 removing 4993192 relations and 2993192 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:00:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:00:43 2017 begin with 357461278 relations and 222180680 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:01:40 2017 reduce to 357407661 relations and 219133209 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:01:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:02:49 2017 removing 4944092 relations and 2944092 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:02:53 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:03:03 2017 begin with 352463569 relations and 219133209 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:04:10 2017 reduce to 352409214 relations and 216134111 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:04:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:05:16 2017 removing 4969888 relations and 2969888 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:05:20 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:05:29 2017 begin with 347439326 relations and 216134111 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:06:24 2017 reduce to 347383018 relations and 213107220 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:06:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:07:28 2017 removing 4967355 relations and 2967355 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:07:32 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:07:41 2017 begin with 342415663 relations and 213107220 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:08:46 2017 reduce to 342361167 relations and 210084735 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:08:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:09:48 2017 removing 4938558 relations and 2938558 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:09:53 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:10:01 2017 begin with 337422609 relations and 210084735 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:10:55 2017 reduce to 337367078 relations and 207089993 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:10:55 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:11:56 2017 removing 4952405 relations and 2952405 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:12:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:12:09 2017 begin with 332414673 relations and 207089993 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:13:01 2017 reduce to 332356029 relations and 204078191 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:13:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:14:02 2017 removing 4962092 relations and 2962092 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:14:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:14:14 2017 begin with 327393937 relations and 204078191 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:15:16 2017 reduce to 327337111 relations and 201058532 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:15:16 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 24 Mon Dec 11 04:16:16 2017 removing 4943748 relations and 2943748 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:16:20 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:16:28 2017 begin with 322393363 relations and 201058532 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:17:29 2017 reduce to 322338059 relations and 198058737 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:17:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:18:27 2017 removing 4942560 relations and 2942560 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:18:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:18:39 2017 begin with 317395499 relations and 198058737 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:19:39 2017 reduce to 317336561 relations and 195056419 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:19:39 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:20:37 2017 removing 4955776 relations and 2955776 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:20:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:20:49 2017 begin with 312380785 relations and 195056419 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:21:38 2017 reduce to 312323068 relations and 192042118 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:21:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:22:34 2017 removing 4910420 relations and 2910420 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:22:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:22:46 2017 begin with 307412648 relations and 192042118 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:23:44 2017 reduce to 307350888 relations and 189069121 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:23:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:24:40 2017 removing 4879496 relations and 2879496 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:24:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:24:52 2017 begin with 302471392 relations and 189069121 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:25:48 2017 reduce to 302405143 relations and 186122521 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:25:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:26:45 2017 removing 4892855 relations and 2892855 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:26:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:26:57 2017 begin with 297512288 relations and 186122521 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:27:45 2017 reduce to 297445529 relations and 183162028 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:27:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:28:40 2017 removing 4963412 relations and 2963412 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:28:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:28:51 2017 begin with 292482117 relations and 183162028 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:29:46 2017 reduce to 292419540 relations and 180135206 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:29:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:30:40 2017 removing 4925439 relations and 2925439 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:30:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:30:51 2017 begin with 287494101 relations and 180135206 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:31:36 2017 reduce to 287431643 relations and 177146476 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:31:36 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:32:29 2017 removing 4923498 relations and 2923498 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:32:33 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:32:40 2017 begin with 282508145 relations and 177146476 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:33:33 2017 reduce to 282445054 relations and 174159028 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:33:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:34:26 2017 removing 4957144 relations and 2957144 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:34:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:34:37 2017 begin with 277487910 relations and 174159028 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:35:23 2017 reduce to 277424661 relations and 171137752 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:35:23 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 23 Mon Dec 11 04:36:16 2017 removing 4926164 relations and 2926164 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:36:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:36:28 2017 begin with 272498497 relations and 171137752 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:37:12 2017 reduce to 272433386 relations and 168145620 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:37:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:38:04 2017 removing 4940850 relations and 2940850 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:38:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:38:15 2017 begin with 267492536 relations and 168145620 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:39:08 2017 reduce to 267427554 relations and 165138864 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:39:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:39:59 2017 removing 4961883 relations and 2961883 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:40:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:40:09 2017 begin with 262465671 relations and 165138864 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:41:01 2017 reduce to 262401394 relations and 162111848 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:41:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:41:49 2017 removing 4939818 relations and 2939818 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:41:53 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:41:59 2017 begin with 257461576 relations and 162111848 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:42:47 2017 reduce to 257395320 relations and 159104886 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:42:47 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:43:35 2017 removing 4929529 relations and 2929529 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:43:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:43:45 2017 begin with 252465791 relations and 159104886 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:44:31 2017 reduce to 252392449 relations and 156101044 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:44:31 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:45:18 2017 removing 4909213 relations and 2909213 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:45:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:45:27 2017 begin with 247483236 relations and 156101044 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:46:12 2017 reduce to 247405662 relations and 153113240 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:46:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:46:58 2017 removing 4918265 relations and 2918265 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:47:01 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:47:07 2017 begin with 242487397 relations and 153113240 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:47:51 2017 reduce to 242408953 relations and 150115444 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:47:51 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 22 Mon Dec 11 04:48:36 2017 removing 4942256 relations and 2942256 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:48:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:48:45 2017 begin with 237466697 relations and 150115444 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:49:28 2017 reduce to 237387948 relations and 147093216 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:49:28 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Mon Dec 11 04:50:12 2017 removing 4967442 relations and 2967442 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:50:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:50:21 2017 begin with 232420506 relations and 147093216 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:51:10 2017 reduce to 232339810 relations and 144043878 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 04:51:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Mon Dec 11 04:51:53 2017 removing 4968425 relations and 2968425 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:51:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:52:02 2017 begin with 227371385 relations and 144043878 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:52:42 2017 reduce to 227289133 relations and 140991964 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:52:42 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 21 Mon Dec 11 04:53:25 2017 removing 4962989 relations and 2962989 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:53:28 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:53:33 2017 begin with 222326144 relations and 140991964 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:54:13 2017 reduce to 222241319 relations and 137942893 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:54:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Mon Dec 11 04:54:55 2017 removing 4964052 relations and 2964052 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:54:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:55:03 2017 begin with 217277267 relations and 137942893 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:55:41 2017 reduce to 217189895 relations and 134890177 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:55:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Mon Dec 11 04:56:22 2017 removing 4998289 relations and 2998289 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:56:25 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:56:30 2017 begin with 212191606 relations and 134890177 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:57:02 2017 reduce to 212101268 relations and 131800128 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:57:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Mon Dec 11 04:57:42 2017 removing 4992858 relations and 2992858 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:57:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:57:49 2017 begin with 207108410 relations and 131800128 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:58:26 2017 reduce to 207017279 relations and 128714755 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 04:58:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 04:59:06 2017 removing 4986938 relations and 2986938 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 04:59:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 04:59:14 2017 begin with 202030341 relations and 128714755 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 04:59:45 2017 reduce to 201927306 relations and 125623173 ideals in 5 passes Mon Dec 11 04:59:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:00:24 2017 removing 4987136 relations and 2987136 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:00:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:00:31 2017 begin with 196940170 relations and 125623173 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:01:07 2017 reduce to 196831073 relations and 122525253 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:01:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:01:44 2017 removing 4995271 relations and 2995271 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:01:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:01:52 2017 begin with 191835802 relations and 122525253 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:02:27 2017 reduce to 191719964 relations and 119412269 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:02:27 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:03:03 2017 removing 5012667 relations and 3012667 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:03:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:03:10 2017 begin with 186707297 relations and 119412269 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:03:48 2017 reduce to 186586873 relations and 116277106 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 05:03:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:04:24 2017 removing 5050465 relations and 3050465 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:04:26 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:04:30 2017 begin with 181536408 relations and 116277106 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:05:02 2017 reduce to 181412639 relations and 113100711 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:05:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:05:37 2017 removing 5070323 relations and 3070323 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:05:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:05:43 2017 begin with 176342316 relations and 113100711 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:06:13 2017 reduce to 176213539 relations and 109899265 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:06:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:06:47 2017 removing 5084245 relations and 3084245 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:06:50 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:06:54 2017 begin with 171129294 relations and 109899265 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:07:24 2017 reduce to 170992965 relations and 106676149 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:07:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Mon Dec 11 05:07:58 2017 removing 5085947 relations and 3085947 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:08:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:08:04 2017 begin with 165907018 relations and 106676149 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:08:38 2017 reduce to 165762183 relations and 103442661 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 05:08:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Mon Dec 11 05:09:11 2017 removing 5103939 relations and 3103939 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:09:14 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:09:18 2017 begin with 160658244 relations and 103442661 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:09:46 2017 reduce to 160503899 relations and 100181472 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:09:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Mon Dec 11 05:10:18 2017 removing 5124848 relations and 3124848 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:10:20 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:10:24 2017 begin with 155379051 relations and 100181472 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:10:56 2017 reduce to 155215951 relations and 96890417 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 05:10:56 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Mon Dec 11 05:11:27 2017 removing 5153317 relations and 3153317 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:11:30 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:11:33 2017 begin with 150062634 relations and 96890417 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:12:09 2017 reduce to 149889520 relations and 93560561 ideals in 8 passes Mon Dec 11 05:12:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Mon Dec 11 05:12:40 2017 removing 5188187 relations and 3188187 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:12:42 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:12:45 2017 begin with 144701333 relations and 93560561 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:13:10 2017 reduce to 144516376 relations and 90183905 ideals in 6 passes Mon Dec 11 05:13:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Mon Dec 11 05:13:40 2017 removing 5214108 relations and 3214108 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:13:42 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:13:45 2017 begin with 139302268 relations and 90183905 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:14:13 2017 reduce to 139105343 relations and 86769020 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 05:14:13 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Mon Dec 11 05:14:42 2017 removing 5253601 relations and 3253601 ideals in 2000000 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:14:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:14:47 2017 begin with 133851742 relations and 86769020 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:15:15 2017 reduce to 133638811 relations and 83298225 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 05:15:15 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Mon Dec 11 05:15:43 2017 removing 3113375 relations and 1933833 ideals in 1179542 cliques Mon Dec 11 05:15:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Mon Dec 11 05:15:48 2017 begin with 130525436 relations and 83298225 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:16:15 2017 reduce to 130418265 relations and 81255732 ideals in 7 passes Mon Dec 11 05:16:15 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 0 large ideals: 9746435 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 1 large ideals: 37152267 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 2 large ideals: 50708038 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 3 large ideals: 26128000 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 4 large ideals: 5817922 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 5 large ideals: 777115 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 6 large ideals: 82589 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 relations with 7+ large ideals: 5899 Mon Dec 11 05:16:47 2017 commencing 2-way merge Mon Dec 11 05:17:24 2017 reduce to 87505972 relation sets and 38343439 unique ideals Mon Dec 11 05:17:24 2017 commencing full merge Mon Dec 11 05:22:42 2017 memory use: 3882.0 MB Mon Dec 11 05:22:49 2017 found 48398060 cycles, need 42380410 Mon Dec 11 05:22:59 2017 weight of 42380410 cycles is about 3735039103 (88.13/cycle) Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 1 relations: 9746435 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 2 relations: 4234332 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 3 relations: 3311133 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 4 relations: 2984003 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 5 relations: 2862011 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 6 relations: 2707594 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 7 relations: 2577730 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 8 relations: 2397264 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 9 relations: 2212662 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 10+ relations: 9347246 Mon Dec 11 05:23:01 2017 heaviest cycle: 19 relations Mon Dec 11 05:23:02 2017 commencing cycle optimization Mon Dec 11 05:23:54 2017 start with 242891120 relations Mon Dec 11 05:28:25 2017 pruned 25702514 relations Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 memory use: 6799.4 MB Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 1 relations: 9746435 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 2 relations: 4440825 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 3 relations: 3612566 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 4 relations: 3361759 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 5 relations: 3351319 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 6 relations: 3247184 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 7 relations: 3125151 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 8 relations: 2829210 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 9 relations: 2480977 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 10+ relations: 6184984 Mon Dec 11 05:28:26 2017 heaviest cycle: 18 relations Mon Dec 11 05:29:24 2017 RelProcTime: 54871 Mon Dec 11 05:29:43 2017 elapsed time 15:14:52 Mon Dec 11 22:47:21 2017 Mon Dec 11 22:47:21 2017 Mon Dec 11 22:47:21 2017 Msieve v. 1.53 (SVN 993) Mon Dec 11 22:47:21 2017 random seeds: 168c9af4 203a89dd Mon Dec 11 22:47:21 2017 factoring 18990123508557902868419834986612849212629329047848408031918356871905091180915018818857084783656883790655928770567349115604303665109625610225945717466120031386943078873289069222693826896799892056101 (197 digits) Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 commencing number field sieve (197-digit input) Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 R0: 119738888098469732352733201 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 R1: -6705343098319824504035000000000000000000000000 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A0: 710432 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A1: 0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A2: 0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A3: 0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A4: 0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A5: 0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 A6: 35 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 skew 5.22, size 2.773e-14, alpha -0.778, combined = 8.262e-15 rroots = 0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 commencing relation filtering Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 setting target matrix density to 134.0 Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 estimated available RAM is 32087.4 MB Mon Dec 11 22:47:22 2017 commencing duplicate removal, pass 1 Mon Dec 11 22:55:07 2017 error -1 reading relation 56850545 Mon Dec 11 22:57:51 2017 error -1 reading relation 77165573 Mon Dec 11 23:00:12 2017 error -1 reading relation 94530616 Mon Dec 11 23:10:46 2017 error -1 reading relation 172655433 Mon Dec 11 23:12:06 2017 error -1 reading relation 182618570 Mon Dec 11 23:12:35 2017 error -1 reading relation 186206132 Mon Dec 11 23:36:32 2017 error -1 reading relation 363634297 Mon Dec 11 23:37:52 2017 error -1 reading relation 373577620 Mon Dec 11 23:42:17 2017 error -6 reading relation 406204558 Mon Dec 11 23:50:43 2017 error -1 reading relation 469065580 Mon Dec 11 23:51:12 2017 error -1 reading relation 472647716 Mon Dec 11 23:53:28 2017 error -11 reading relation 489251211 Tue Dec 12 00:02:17 2017 error -1 reading relation 554604768 Tue Dec 12 00:14:53 2017 skipped 3208 relations with b > 2^32 Tue Dec 12 00:14:53 2017 found 80451336 hash collisions in 646740456 relations Tue Dec 12 00:15:05 2017 added 1624 free relations Tue Dec 12 00:15:05 2017 commencing duplicate removal, pass 2 Tue Dec 12 00:19:45 2017 found 0 duplicates and 646742080 unique relations Tue Dec 12 00:19:45 2017 memory use: 4262.0 MB Tue Dec 12 00:19:46 2017 reading ideals above 534970368 Tue Dec 12 00:19:46 2017 commencing singleton removal, initial pass Tue Dec 12 01:24:23 2017 memory use: 11024.0 MB Tue Dec 12 01:24:24 2017 reading all ideals from disk Tue Dec 12 01:24:46 2017 memory use: 11692.3 MB Tue Dec 12 01:25:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 01:26:07 2017 begin with 646742080 relations and 440359514 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 01:31:14 2017 reduce to 539490269 relations and 328011191 ideals in 10 passes Tue Dec 12 01:31:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 43 Tue Dec 12 01:31:48 2017 reading ideals above 720000 Tue Dec 12 01:31:49 2017 commencing singleton removal, initial pass Tue Dec 12 02:45:12 2017 memory use: 11024.0 MB Tue Dec 12 02:45:12 2017 reading large ideals from disk Tue Dec 12 02:49:34 2017 keeping 341820068 ideals with weight <= 20, target excess is 42369947 Tue Dec 12 02:59:02 2017 memory use: 13971.2 MB Tue Dec 12 02:59:02 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 02:59:18 2017 begin with 539490269 relations and 341820068 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:00:53 2017 reduce to 539490155 relations and 341819954 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:00:53 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:02:48 2017 removing 10144819 relations and 8144819 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:02:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:03:10 2017 begin with 529345336 relations and 341819954 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:05:20 2017 reduce to 529183542 relations and 333512401 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 03:05:20 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:07:12 2017 removing 7802379 relations and 5802379 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:07:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:07:33 2017 begin with 521381163 relations and 333512401 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:09:21 2017 reduce to 521270188 relations and 327598504 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:09:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:11:10 2017 removing 7063083 relations and 5063083 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:11:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:11:31 2017 begin with 514207105 relations and 327598504 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:13:17 2017 reduce to 514111735 relations and 322439650 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:13:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:15:04 2017 removing 6684809 relations and 4684809 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:15:10 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:15:24 2017 begin with 507426926 relations and 322439650 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:17:26 2017 reduce to 507341295 relations and 317668831 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 03:17:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:19:12 2017 removing 6405029 relations and 4405029 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:19:18 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:19:32 2017 begin with 500936266 relations and 317668831 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:20:57 2017 reduce to 500855337 relations and 313182491 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:20:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:22:43 2017 removing 6233416 relations and 4233416 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:22:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:23:03 2017 begin with 494621921 relations and 313182491 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:24:46 2017 reduce to 494546854 relations and 308873667 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:24:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:26:29 2017 removing 6078923 relations and 4078923 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:26:35 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:26:49 2017 begin with 488467931 relations and 308873667 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:28:11 2017 reduce to 488395119 relations and 304721612 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:28:11 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:29:54 2017 removing 5988490 relations and 3988490 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:30:00 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:30:13 2017 begin with 482406629 relations and 304721612 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:31:35 2017 reduce to 482338442 relations and 300664591 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:31:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:33:15 2017 removing 5874550 relations and 3874550 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:33:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:33:34 2017 begin with 476463892 relations and 300664591 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:35:10 2017 reduce to 476396277 relations and 296722067 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:35:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:36:49 2017 removing 5791180 relations and 3791180 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:36:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:37:08 2017 begin with 470605097 relations and 296722067 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:38:43 2017 reduce to 470539344 relations and 292864790 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:38:43 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:40:22 2017 removing 5736856 relations and 3736856 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:40:28 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:40:41 2017 begin with 464802488 relations and 292864790 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:42:14 2017 reduce to 464737707 relations and 289062777 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:42:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:43:51 2017 removing 5680368 relations and 3680368 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:43:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:44:10 2017 begin with 459057339 relations and 289062777 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:45:42 2017 reduce to 458995474 relations and 285320164 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:45:42 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:47:18 2017 removing 5615404 relations and 3615404 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:47:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:47:36 2017 begin with 453380070 relations and 285320164 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:49:07 2017 reduce to 453318083 relations and 281642394 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 03:49:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:50:41 2017 removing 5566494 relations and 3566494 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:50:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:50:59 2017 begin with 447751589 relations and 281642394 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:52:14 2017 reduce to 447689797 relations and 278013746 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:52:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:53:48 2017 removing 5550021 relations and 3550021 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:53:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:54:06 2017 begin with 442139776 relations and 278013746 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:55:19 2017 reduce to 442078884 relations and 274402456 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:55:19 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:56:52 2017 removing 5486960 relations and 3486960 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:56:57 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 03:57:09 2017 begin with 436591924 relations and 274402456 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 03:58:21 2017 reduce to 436531240 relations and 270854428 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 03:58:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 03:59:53 2017 removing 5476805 relations and 3476805 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 03:59:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:00:10 2017 begin with 431054435 relations and 270854428 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:01:35 2017 reduce to 430996300 relations and 267319073 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:01:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:03:06 2017 removing 5452935 relations and 3452935 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:03:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:03:23 2017 begin with 425543365 relations and 267319073 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:04:33 2017 reduce to 425485114 relations and 263807476 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:04:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:06:03 2017 removing 5361079 relations and 3361079 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:06:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:06:20 2017 begin with 420124035 relations and 263807476 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:07:43 2017 reduce to 420062423 relations and 260384339 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:07:43 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:09:12 2017 removing 5372802 relations and 3372802 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:09:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:09:28 2017 begin with 414689621 relations and 260384339 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:10:50 2017 reduce to 414627437 relations and 256948843 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:10:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:12:18 2017 removing 5342650 relations and 3342650 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:12:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:12:34 2017 begin with 409284787 relations and 256948843 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:14:08 2017 reduce to 409224458 relations and 253545420 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 04:14:08 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:15:34 2017 removing 5354611 relations and 3354611 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:15:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:15:50 2017 begin with 403869847 relations and 253545420 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:17:09 2017 reduce to 403812473 relations and 250133006 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:17:09 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:18:34 2017 removing 5276912 relations and 3276912 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:18:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:18:50 2017 begin with 398535561 relations and 250133006 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:19:55 2017 reduce to 398476530 relations and 246796614 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:19:55 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:21:19 2017 removing 5312161 relations and 3312161 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:21:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:21:35 2017 begin with 393164369 relations and 246796614 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:22:39 2017 reduce to 393106941 relations and 243426551 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:22:39 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:24:02 2017 removing 5271798 relations and 3271798 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:24:07 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:24:17 2017 begin with 387835143 relations and 243426551 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:25:33 2017 reduce to 387777601 relations and 240096722 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:25:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:26:54 2017 removing 5248302 relations and 3248302 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:26:59 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:27:10 2017 begin with 382529299 relations and 240096722 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:28:24 2017 reduce to 382469636 relations and 236788232 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:28:24 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:29:45 2017 removing 5176077 relations and 3176077 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:29:50 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:30:00 2017 begin with 377293559 relations and 236788232 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:31:01 2017 reduce to 377228143 relations and 233546174 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:31:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:32:20 2017 removing 5238150 relations and 3238150 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:32:25 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:32:35 2017 begin with 371989993 relations and 233546174 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:33:35 2017 reduce to 371929470 relations and 230246974 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:33:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:34:54 2017 removing 5215833 relations and 3215833 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:34:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:35:08 2017 begin with 366713637 relations and 230246974 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:36:07 2017 reduce to 366654158 relations and 226971124 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:36:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:37:24 2017 removing 5179458 relations and 3179458 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:37:29 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:37:38 2017 begin with 361474700 relations and 226971124 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:38:48 2017 reduce to 361413685 relations and 223730054 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:38:48 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:40:04 2017 removing 5188001 relations and 3188001 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:40:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:40:18 2017 begin with 356225684 relations and 223730054 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:41:26 2017 reduce to 356167225 relations and 220483001 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:41:26 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:42:41 2017 removing 5181796 relations and 3181796 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:42:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:42:55 2017 begin with 350985429 relations and 220483001 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:43:52 2017 reduce to 350924811 relations and 217240045 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:43:52 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:45:05 2017 removing 5137925 relations and 3137925 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:45:09 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:45:18 2017 begin with 345786886 relations and 217240045 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:46:25 2017 reduce to 345726329 relations and 214040945 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:46:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:47:36 2017 removing 5171664 relations and 3171664 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:47:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:47:49 2017 begin with 340554665 relations and 214040945 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:48:44 2017 reduce to 340495767 relations and 210809736 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:48:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:49:54 2017 removing 5120687 relations and 3120687 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:49:58 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:50:07 2017 begin with 335375080 relations and 210809736 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:51:10 2017 reduce to 335313647 relations and 207626960 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:51:10 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:52:19 2017 removing 5131941 relations and 3131941 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:52:24 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:52:32 2017 begin with 330181706 relations and 207626960 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:53:35 2017 reduce to 330120259 relations and 204432944 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 04:53:35 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:54:42 2017 removing 5112367 relations and 3112367 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:54:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:54:55 2017 begin with 325007892 relations and 204432944 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:55:46 2017 reduce to 324945239 relations and 201257234 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:55:46 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:56:51 2017 removing 5132267 relations and 3132267 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:56:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:57:04 2017 begin with 319812972 relations and 201257234 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 04:57:54 2017 reduce to 319751267 relations and 198062584 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 04:57:54 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 04:58:59 2017 removing 5078866 relations and 3078866 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 04:59:03 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 04:59:11 2017 begin with 314672401 relations and 198062584 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:00:01 2017 reduce to 314609791 relations and 194920440 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 05:00:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:01:04 2017 removing 5100056 relations and 3100056 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:01:08 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:01:16 2017 begin with 309509735 relations and 194920440 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:02:14 2017 reduce to 309444828 relations and 191754762 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:02:14 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:03:17 2017 removing 4992287 relations and 2992287 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:03:21 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:03:28 2017 begin with 304452541 relations and 191754762 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:04:25 2017 reduce to 304377705 relations and 188686802 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:04:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:05:27 2017 removing 5097317 relations and 3097317 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:05:31 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:05:38 2017 begin with 299280388 relations and 188686802 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:06:34 2017 reduce to 299213225 relations and 185521562 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:06:34 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:07:35 2017 removing 5066936 relations and 3066936 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:07:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:07:46 2017 begin with 294146289 relations and 185521562 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:08:41 2017 reduce to 294080268 relations and 182387864 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:08:41 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:09:39 2017 removing 5076930 relations and 3076930 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:09:43 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:09:51 2017 begin with 289003338 relations and 182387864 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:10:45 2017 reduce to 288934841 relations and 179241653 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:10:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:11:42 2017 removing 5081011 relations and 3081011 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:11:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:11:53 2017 begin with 283853830 relations and 179241653 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:12:55 2017 reduce to 283789136 relations and 176095178 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:12:55 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:13:51 2017 removing 5024219 relations and 3024219 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:13:55 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:14:02 2017 begin with 278764917 relations and 176095178 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:14:45 2017 reduce to 278696598 relations and 173001773 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 05:14:45 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:15:40 2017 removing 5064270 relations and 3064270 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:15:44 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:15:51 2017 begin with 273632328 relations and 173001773 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:16:42 2017 reduce to 273560614 relations and 169864906 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:16:42 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:17:36 2017 removing 5066148 relations and 3066148 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:17:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:17:46 2017 begin with 268494466 relations and 169864906 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:18:28 2017 reduce to 268426873 relations and 166730314 ideals in 5 passes Tue Dec 12 05:18:28 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:19:20 2017 removing 5069098 relations and 3069098 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:19:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:19:30 2017 begin with 263357775 relations and 166730314 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:20:18 2017 reduce to 263285086 relations and 163587598 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:20:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:21:08 2017 removing 5041997 relations and 3041997 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:21:11 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:21:18 2017 begin with 258243089 relations and 163587598 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:22:05 2017 reduce to 258169708 relations and 160471291 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:22:05 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:22:53 2017 removing 5045525 relations and 3045525 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:22:56 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:23:03 2017 begin with 253124183 relations and 160471291 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:23:49 2017 reduce to 253051057 relations and 157351710 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:23:49 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 20 Tue Dec 12 05:24:36 2017 removing 5057015 relations and 3057015 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:24:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:24:45 2017 begin with 247994042 relations and 157351710 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:25:38 2017 reduce to 247916638 relations and 154216270 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:25:38 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:26:23 2017 removing 5000627 relations and 3000627 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:26:27 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:26:33 2017 begin with 242916011 relations and 154216270 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:27:17 2017 reduce to 242829085 relations and 151127558 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:27:17 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:28:02 2017 removing 5000482 relations and 3000482 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:28:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:28:11 2017 begin with 237828603 relations and 151127558 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:28:53 2017 reduce to 237741461 relations and 148038693 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:28:53 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:29:37 2017 removing 5037999 relations and 3037999 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:29:41 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:29:46 2017 begin with 232703462 relations and 148038693 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:30:28 2017 reduce to 232616387 relations and 144912437 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:30:28 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:31:11 2017 removing 5059338 relations and 3059338 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:31:15 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:31:20 2017 begin with 227557049 relations and 144912437 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:32:01 2017 reduce to 227469857 relations and 141764611 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:32:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:32:43 2017 removing 5082936 relations and 3082936 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:32:46 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:32:52 2017 begin with 222386921 relations and 141764611 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:33:32 2017 reduce to 222301070 relations and 138594568 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:33:32 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:34:14 2017 removing 5049271 relations and 3049271 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:34:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:34:22 2017 begin with 217251799 relations and 138594568 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:35:01 2017 reduce to 217161133 relations and 135453319 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:35:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 19 Tue Dec 12 05:35:42 2017 removing 5082027 relations and 3082027 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:35:45 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:35:50 2017 begin with 212079106 relations and 135453319 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:36:33 2017 reduce to 211986232 relations and 132277137 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:36:33 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:37:13 2017 removing 5062633 relations and 3062633 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:37:16 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:37:21 2017 begin with 206923599 relations and 132277137 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:37:57 2017 reduce to 206832725 relations and 129122223 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:37:57 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:38:36 2017 removing 5087166 relations and 3087166 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:38:39 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:38:44 2017 begin with 201745559 relations and 129122223 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:39:25 2017 reduce to 201648656 relations and 125936720 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:39:25 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:40:02 2017 removing 5085230 relations and 3085230 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:40:05 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:40:10 2017 begin with 196563426 relations and 125936720 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:40:44 2017 reduce to 196458384 relations and 122744822 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:40:44 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:41:21 2017 removing 5053893 relations and 3053893 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:41:23 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:41:28 2017 begin with 191404491 relations and 122744822 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:42:01 2017 reduce to 191290586 relations and 119575413 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:42:01 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:42:37 2017 removing 5074429 relations and 3074429 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:42:40 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:42:44 2017 begin with 186216157 relations and 119575413 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:43:16 2017 reduce to 186093450 relations and 116376452 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:43:16 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:43:51 2017 removing 5082795 relations and 3082795 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:43:54 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:43:58 2017 begin with 181010655 relations and 116376452 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:44:29 2017 reduce to 180881250 relations and 113162264 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:44:29 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:45:03 2017 removing 5093563 relations and 3093563 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:45:06 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:45:10 2017 begin with 175787687 relations and 113162264 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:45:40 2017 reduce to 175652392 relations and 109931268 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:45:40 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:46:14 2017 removing 5106075 relations and 3106075 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:46:17 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:46:21 2017 begin with 170546317 relations and 109931268 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:46:50 2017 reduce to 170402856 relations and 106679377 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:46:50 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:47:23 2017 removing 5167881 relations and 3167881 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:47:26 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:47:30 2017 begin with 165234975 relations and 106679377 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:48:02 2017 reduce to 165089276 relations and 103363338 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:48:02 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:48:35 2017 removing 5190574 relations and 3190574 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:48:37 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:48:41 2017 begin with 159898702 relations and 103363338 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:49:12 2017 reduce to 159749801 relations and 100021385 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:49:12 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 18 Tue Dec 12 05:49:44 2017 removing 5234178 relations and 3234178 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:49:47 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:49:50 2017 begin with 154515623 relations and 100021385 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:50:16 2017 reduce to 154357861 relations and 96626749 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:50:16 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Tue Dec 12 05:50:47 2017 removing 5260927 relations and 3260927 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:50:49 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:50:53 2017 begin with 149096934 relations and 96626749 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:51:18 2017 reduce to 148939198 relations and 93205293 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:51:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Tue Dec 12 05:51:48 2017 removing 5281981 relations and 3281981 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:51:50 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:51:53 2017 begin with 143657217 relations and 93205293 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:52:21 2017 reduce to 143469710 relations and 89732419 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:52:21 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Tue Dec 12 05:52:50 2017 removing 5281925 relations and 3281925 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:52:52 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:52:55 2017 begin with 138187785 relations and 89732419 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:53:18 2017 reduce to 137975753 relations and 86234593 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:53:18 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Tue Dec 12 05:53:45 2017 removing 5372526 relations and 3372526 ideals in 2000000 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:53:48 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:53:50 2017 begin with 132603227 relations and 86234593 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:54:15 2017 reduce to 132397218 relations and 82652018 ideals in 7 passes Tue Dec 12 05:54:15 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Tue Dec 12 05:54:42 2017 removing 1569336 relations and 973275 ideals in 596061 cliques Tue Dec 12 05:54:43 2017 commencing in-memory singleton removal Tue Dec 12 05:54:46 2017 begin with 130827882 relations and 82652018 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:55:07 2017 reduce to 130795950 relations and 81646670 ideals in 6 passes Tue Dec 12 05:55:07 2017 max relations containing the same ideal: 17 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 0 large ideals: 9874130 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 1 large ideals: 36781067 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 2 large ideals: 50406505 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 3 large ideals: 26758902 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 4 large ideals: 6096114 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 5 large ideals: 791279 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 6 large ideals: 82050 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 relations with 7+ large ideals: 5903 Tue Dec 12 05:55:37 2017 commencing 2-way merge Tue Dec 12 05:56:13 2017 reduce to 88621891 relation sets and 39472611 unique ideals Tue Dec 12 05:56:13 2017 commencing full merge Tue Dec 12 06:01:36 2017 memory use: 3952.7 MB Tue Dec 12 06:01:44 2017 found 48241015 cycles, need 42370147 Tue Dec 12 06:01:54 2017 weight of 42370147 cycles is about 3820560163 (90.17/cycle) Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 1 relations: 9874130 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 2 relations: 4230507 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 3 relations: 3248686 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 4 relations: 2878304 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 5 relations: 2738667 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 6 relations: 2592853 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 7 relations: 2472731 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 8 relations: 2307398 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 9 relations: 2149314 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 10+ relations: 9877557 Tue Dec 12 06:01:55 2017 heaviest cycle: 19 relations Tue Dec 12 06:01:57 2017 commencing cycle optimization Tue Dec 12 06:02:48 2017 start with 247928841 relations Tue Dec 12 06:07:32 2017 pruned 26935292 relations Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 memory use: 6842.5 MB Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 distribution of cycle lengths: Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 1 relations: 9874130 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 2 relations: 4436683 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 3 relations: 3540445 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 4 relations: 3239616 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 5 relations: 3201475 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 6 relations: 3105799 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 7 relations: 3005730 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 8 relations: 2751405 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 9 relations: 2458387 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 10+ relations: 6756477 Tue Dec 12 06:07:33 2017 heaviest cycle: 19 relations Tue Dec 12 06:08:31 2017 RelProcTime: 26469 Tue Dec 12 06:08:50 2017 elapsed time 07:21:29 Tue Dec 12 17:10:38 2017 Tue Dec 12 17:10:38 2017 Tue Dec 12 17:10:38 2017 Msieve v. 1.53 (SVN 993) Tue Dec 12 17:10:38 2017 random seeds: 5c43783d 4d298a90 Tue Dec 12 17:10:38 2017 factoring 18990123508557902868419834986612849212629329047848408031918356871905091180915018818857084783656883790655928770567349115604303665109625610225945717466120031386943078873289069222693826896799892056101 (197 digits) Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 commencing number field sieve (197-digit input) Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 R0: 119738888098469732352733201 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 R1: -6705343098319824504035000000000000000000000000 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A0: 710432 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A1: 0 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A2: 0 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A3: 0 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A4: 0 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A5: 0 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 A6: 35 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 skew 5.22, size 2.773e-14, alpha -0.778, combined = 8.262e-15 rroots = 0 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 Tue Dec 12 17:10:39 2017 commencing linear algebra Tue Dec 12 17:10:42 2017 read 42370147 cycles Tue Dec 12 17:11:29 2017 cycles contain 111947343 unique relations Tue Dec 12 17:22:33 2017 read 111947343 relations Tue Dec 12 17:25:50 2017 using 20 quadratic characters above 4294917295 Tue Dec 12 17:33:53 2017 building initial matrix Tue Dec 12 17:54:03 2017 memory use: 15757.5 MB Tue Dec 12 17:54:16 2017 read 42370147 cycles Tue Dec 12 17:54:21 2017 matrix is 42350782 x 42370147 (14213.5 MB) with weight 4191733075 (98.93/col) Tue Dec 12 17:54:21 2017 sparse part has weight 3259899085 (76.94/col) Tue Dec 12 18:07:29 2017 filtering completed in 3 passes Tue Dec 12 18:07:37 2017 matrix is 41982372 x 41982572 (14135.8 MB) with weight 4167899249 (99.28/col) Tue Dec 12 18:07:37 2017 sparse part has weight 3243815325 (77.27/col) Tue Dec 12 18:09:07 2017 matrix starts at (0, 0) Tue Dec 12 18:09:13 2017 matrix is 41982372 x 41982572 (14135.8 MB) with weight 4167899249 (99.28/col) Tue Dec 12 18:09:13 2017 sparse part has weight 3243815325 (77.27/col) Tue Dec 12 18:09:13 2017 saving the first 48 matrix rows for later Tue Dec 12 18:09:17 2017 matrix includes 64 packed rows Tue Dec 12 18:09:22 2017 matrix is 41982324 x 41982572 (13608.3 MB) with weight 3416297546 (81.37/col) Tue Dec 12 18:09:22 2017 sparse part has weight 3147500232 (74.97/col) Tue Dec 12 18:09:22 2017 using block size 8192 and superblock size 1474560 for processor cache size 15360 kB Tue Dec 12 18:12:55 2017 commencing Lanczos iteration (6 threads) Tue Dec 12 18:12:55 2017 memory use: 11769.5 MB Tue Dec 12 18:17:02 2017 linear algebra at 0.0%, ETA 1815h21m Tue Dec 12 18:18:24 2017 checkpointing every 30000 dimensions Mon Jan 29 16:41:47 2018 lanczos halted after 663899 iterations (dim = 41982252) Mon Jan 29 16:42:22 2018 recovered 2 nontrivial dependencies Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 BLanczosTime: 4145507 Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 elapsed time 1151:31:48 Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 Msieve v. 1.53 (SVN 993) Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 random seeds: 6e8a9003 79c3c7f3 Mon Jan 29 16:42:26 2018 factoring 18990123508557902868419834986612849212629329047848408031918356871905091180915018818857084783656883790655928770567349115604303665109625610225945717466120031386943078873289069222693826896799892056101 (197 digits) Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 commencing number field sieve (197-digit input) Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 R0: 119738888098469732352733201 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 R1: -6705343098319824504035000000000000000000000000 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A0: 710432 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A1: 0 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A2: 0 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A3: 0 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A4: 0 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A5: 0 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 A6: 35 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 skew 5.22, size 2.773e-14, alpha -0.778, combined = 8.262e-15 rroots = 0 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 commencing square root phase Mon Jan 29 16:42:27 2018 reading relations for dependency 1 Mon Jan 29 16:42:30 2018 read 20992746 cycles Mon Jan 29 16:42:52 2018 cycles contain 55771226 unique relations Mon Jan 29 16:48:58 2018 read 55771226 relations Mon Jan 29 16:52:31 2018 multiplying 55771226 relations Mon Jan 29 17:51:26 2018 multiply complete, coefficients have about 1867.50 million bits Mon Jan 29 17:51:31 2018 initial square root is modulo 238270447 Mon Jan 29 18:50:25 2018 sqrtTime: 7678 Mon Jan 29 18:50:25 2018 p77 factor: 17881434939286116906005290845928024997562534612043549094809723622096444512601 Mon Jan 29 18:50:25 2018 p121 factor: 1062002214757159097172539850510404685048452573809361284279832082914319803525039974655315341035549161888830809328709443501 Mon Jan 29 18:50:25 2018 elapsed time 02:07:59